Charlie turned 3 years old this month! Since he’s hit all of his big milestones, this will be my last monthly update for him. But I’ll still pop in with Charlie stories when they’re relevant to parenting! A lot of things have actually been happening in his little life lately, from sleep to behavior and everything in between. We’ve made a lot of changes in the past month to address those issues, and I think it might be helpful if you’re struggling with some of the same problems!
Charlie getting a haircut at a local barber shop.
Naps
For the past couple of months, getting Charlie down for naps has been a challenge, even though he is the best napper out of all the kids at daycare. It’s quite common for kids to nap and behave much better at daycare than at home because they misbehave with the people they’re most comfortable with. We knew he still needed his nap because he’d usually melt down around bedtime whenever he skipped a nap. We’d resorted to stroller napping him every weekend for the past month, but even that stopped working recently. So we instituted quiet time every afternoon over the holiday break. He doesn’t have to take a nap, but he does have to play quietly in his room for an hour. Amazingly he stays in there, even though he protests quiet time every day. He’s napped twice, but most of the time he doesn’t. So what does he do in that hour? We can watch him on the video monitor (which has a great scroll feature), and he does puzzles, reads books, and random things like putting three shirts on top of one another.
So far it’s been working great. He hasn’t melted down since we instituted quiet time, I think because he has a chance to play calmly and quietly and reset. His bedtime is also earlier — between 7:00 – 7:30 –because he’s more tired without a nap. I can’t say that I don’t miss his 3-4 hour monster naps because that afternoon break sure was great, but at least the nap battles and overtired meltdowns have ceased. I’m sure he’ll still continue to nap well at daycare, and will fall asleep in the stroller if we’re out and about and he’s tired, but I think his daytime naps at home may largely be a thing of the past now. He’s just too busy to want to stop playing to take a nap. The up side is we’re not burned out from bedtime battles anymore, and our nights are now freeeeee (to work that is!)!
Bedtime
While we were battling naps, bedtime was also often a challenge. Charlie would make excuses to extend the bedtime routine most nights, saying he was hungry, he wasn’t tired, he needed to use the potty… and most of the time he’d actually poop so what could we do! He’d come out of his room multiple times. He’d turn on his bedroom light after we left (so we put a childproof lock on his light switch which has worked great). But Mr. Bee recently started leaving Charlie’s bedroom door wide open, and bedtime has consistently been good since. He stays in his room after stories, and falls asleep on his own even though he can hear us cleaning up and chatting. Bedtime has been an up and down battle for pretty much the entire past year, especially after we transitioned to a toddler bed, and hopefully we’ve finally nipped it in the bud!
Behavior
The past two months have been very challenging, at times, when it comes to Charlie’s behavior. I think we escaped the Terrible Twos relatively unscathed. We didn’t do time outs, we really listened and empathized with Charlie, and we practiced positive parenting. For the most part, Charlie was well behaved, and the occasional tantrums he had (1-2 times a week) were usually the result of being overtired or hungry. But recently Charlie started throwing frequent tantrums (several times a day), throwing tantrums as soon as he woke up for absolutely no reason, being defiant, and simply not listening to us. My mom visited recently, and she noticed the change in Charlie’s behavior since the last time she saw him three months ago. I feared that the Terrible Threes were upon us, which are supposed to be much, much worse than the Terrible Twos!
When the problems first started, I suspected that Charlie might have a sleep deficit. A sleep deficit of just an hour a day over a couple of days can have an impact on behavior, and Charlie’s bedtime had been an hour or two later for some time since he would fight bedtime so much. So we got super strict with following a morning and night time routine chart, and tried moving bedtime earlier by 15 minutes at a time until he was sleeping by 8pm at the latest.
That didn’t have much impact so we asked Dr. Tom (a clinical child psychologist) for some advice. He told us to use our actions instead of our words when it came to dealing with any behavioral and sleep issues. As your child becomes increasingly verbal, I think the natural instinct is to try to explain things to them and reason with them. But you often can’t reason with a 3 year old, so it can be much more powerful to focus on how your actions are training your child. For instance, Charlie would run around after his bath, and we’d keep coming in his room telling him to go to sleep. He loved the attention and we trained him to misbehave by continuing to pay attention to him every night. So we changed our actions — if Charlie didn’t put on his pj’s/brush his teeth/etc., we’d tell him that we’d leave the room and immediately follow through. He stopped his bedtime shenanigans because he didn’t want us to leave. Changing our actions changed his actions. Charlie listens to us much better now!
That was a helpful tool in our parenting toolkit, but we were still dealing with tantrums and defiance issues.
We implemented a rewards chart a month and a half ago to help with Charlie’s behavioral issues, but it didn’t work that well so we put it to the side for a while. He simply wasn’t interested in the rewards, which was a toy of his choice for good behavior. In fact rewards haven’t worked well for Charlie in general whether it’s praise, stickers, toys, going out, candy, videos, etc. The boy is hard to bribe! For example, I recently told Charlie that if he didn’t clean up his blocks after playing with them, I’d give them to a little boy who didn’t get any presents for Christmas. Charlie not only told me to take his blocks, but also told me to give away a slew of other toys as well. Whenever I tell him that I’m going to donate his toys, he doesn’t care when I bag them up, and even helps me do it!
We still decided to give the rewards chart another try because I really want to blog about it — I think it can be a very effective tool for most parents. Hopefully this time around it works. We’ve been using it for the past couple of days, and he still doesn’t care too much about the rewards, whatever they may be. The past couple of days he has been exceptionally well behaved however — perhaps it’s because we instituted quiet time and bedtime has been going seamlessly.
One big change we made over the holiday break was to institute a schedule, similar to daycare, so that Charlie has a general idea of what to expect each day. From art time to outdoor time to education time, we’ve been planning out our entire day ahead of time. Children thrive on consistency, and I think this will have a big impact on his behavior. Since we’re spending a lot more time indoors anyway because it’s so cold out, it actually makes our days much more fun to have planned activities each day. I have a big post on all this coming up because so far, so good!
Eating
I think eating will always be a challenge with Charlie and he has his days where he hardly eats anything at all, but he continues to eat better than he ever has since we went gluten-free and started using the Innobaby Bus Platter. He actually says he’s hungry sometimes, which is something he never used to do. Just yesterday he ate a huge breakfast, a big lunch, a huge snack, a light dinner, and another huge snack after dinner. It’s the most he’s ever eaten in a single day in his life!
We recently gifted a play market that he adores to Charlie’s daycare, and because he’s been learning about all kinds of different vegetables, I think it has helped him be more interested in trying new foods. Books about fussy eaters like I Will Never Not Eat a Tomato also seem to help (especially since the main character’s name is Charlie!).
Puzzles
Charlie is obsessed with puzzles lately and we have so much to say about them, there are 2 posts forthcoming! Charlie can spend several hours a day every day on puzzles! He asks for help with the 60 piece puzzles we bought over the weekend, but I think he can do them on his own. He just likes us to sit with him when he does puzzles…. and most things in general. As a first child, he is much needier and dependent on us than Olive, who is used to being much more independent as a second child.
Charlie has always loved getting his hair cut. Here he’s watching Thomas the Tank Engine on my iPhone — a surefire way to get him to sit still for just about anything.
Talking
As much as he cracks me up, I do miss the days when Charlie was under 2 because sometimes I get tired of answering his million why questions. He is such a chatterbox! His ability to recount something he’s heard once is pretty uncanny. His memory is better than mine (although that’s not saying much).
Here are a couple of his recent sayings:
Charlie: Daddy you’re nice to me but I’m not nice to you. How does that make you feel?
****
Charlie: (touches my stomach, 14 months postpartum) Mommy, is there a baby in there?
****
Charlie: (coughs weakly) I think that I’m sick Daddy.
Mr. Bee: Oh ok. Then we’ll stay home today. We won’t go to the library, the playground or the bookstore.
Charlie: (thinks about it) I think that I feel better now, Daddy.
****
Charlie: Olive, you’re dirty, yucky, crazy, cute!
****
Me: Charlie! (after he’s being naughty) I need a Charlie-cation!
Charlie: What kind of -cation do I need mama? Do I need a mama-cation?
My Little Boy
Charlie has been going through a mama phase lately, and when it’s just the two of us, we have so much fun! He is such a sweet boy, not just to us, but to his teachers and friends. He is constantly saying I love you and giving copious hugs and kisses. He has a big personality, but is usually a little shy in new situations. He gets along so well with Olive. He is so earnest! I think he’s pretty smart (objectively ;)). It’s truly incredible to think about how much he’s grown, learned, and changed in the past year, and his life has only just begun! What a privilege it is to watch him grow up and become his own person. I truly do feel lucky to be his mama every single day.
I thought it would be fun to do one of these interviews each year with Charlie and see how his answers change from year to year!
What is your favorite color? Blue.
What is your favorite toy? yellow doggie
What is your favorite fruit? (Asian) pear
What is your favorite vegetable? pickles
What is your favorite book? Big Pumpkin
Who is your best friend? Mommy, Mommy, Mommy! (though he has many best friends and if Mr. Bee asked the question, he’d say “Daddy.”
What makes you happy? Mama, Daddy, and milky!
What’s your favorite animal? fox
What’s your favorite game? Don’t Break the Ice
What’s your favorite thing to do outside? dig
What’s your favorite tv show? Thomas
What’s something that’s scary? The dentist in Finding Nemo
Where is your favorite place to go? The playground
What’s your favorite song? Pat-a-cake
What do you want to be for Halloween next year? A bumblebee!
What do you want to be when you grow up? Firefighter
Charlie’s Monthly Updates part 36 of 37
1. The Journey to Charlie by Mrs. Bee2. Charlie's Birth Story by Mrs. Bee
3. 1 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
4. 2 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
5. 3 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
6. 4 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
7. 5 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
8. 6 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
9. 7 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
10. 8 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
11. 9 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
12. 10 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
13. 11 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
14. 12-13 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
15. 13 1/2 Month Update - The Turning Point by Mrs. Bee
16. 14 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
17. 15 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
18. 16 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
19. 17 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
20. 18 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
21. 19 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
22. 20 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
23. 21 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
24. 22 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
25. Charlie's 23 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
26. Charlie's 24 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
27. 25 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
28. Charlie's 26 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
29. Olive 5 Months & Charlie 27 Months by Mrs. Bee
30. 7 Month & 29 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
31. 8 Month & 2 1/2 Year Update by Mrs. Bee
32. 9 Month and 31 Month Updates by Mrs. Bee
33. 10 Month & 32 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
34. 11 Month and 33 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
35. 13 Month and 35 Month Update by Mrs. Bee
36. Charlie 3 Year Update by Mrs. Bee
37. Charlie's 4 Year Update by Mrs. Bee
GOLD / wonderful apricot / 22276 posts
What a sweetheart! He is so darn cute
blogger / pomelo / 5361 posts
Cute! I’m interested to hear some examples of using your actions, not your words.
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
@Mrs. Blue: i had one in there originally… editing the post a bit now!
clementine / 826 posts
What a handsome boy!
pomegranate / 3225 posts
his little comments are too funny!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
Aww the end of monthly posts!! I hope you’ll still do some updates – maybe half-year updates? I will be really interested to hear how you deal with behavioral issues – I’m so scared for that!!
Also – LOVE the book I will never not ever eat a tomato – Charlie and Lola are my favorite.
It’s amazing to hear some of the things that go through his mind that you wouldn’t peg a 3-year-old for noticing – in reference to his comment about Mr. Bee being nice to him, but Charlie not returning the favor. Very interesting! Does he genuinely care about how that makes Mr. Bee feel?
wonderful clementine / 24134 posts
I love his shirt in these pictures.
blogger / pineapple / 12381 posts
I think he’s so earnest and sweet because you guys have done such a good job with him. I really feel like I know him through your posts.
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@Mrs. Pen: He does seem to care a lot about our feelings, until suddenly he doesn’t haha.
guest
that interview kills me- so cute!!
grapefruit / 4649 posts
What a lovely 3 year old update! I especially love the interview and the last photo!
It is a bit of an odd idea but I thought I would throw out there a twist on the reward chart. With some of the kids I have worked with in the past we skipped the traditional style and just hung a single sheet of construction paper up with their name on it. Anytime they were “caught” doing the right thing we told them they could put up a sticker. There was no reward other then being caught and getting to put a sticker on the chart. They loved this idea so much more then all of the other ones I have ever tried.
It was also great for my own attitude because I was always on the look out for great behavior– the nice manners that weren’t prompted, not fussing over something they usually fuss about etc. When we eventually phased it out we kept the idea and now give out “imaginary gold stars” they get so excited to be recognized for doing the right thing.
blogger / persimmon / 1398 posts
Awww… what a fabulous post! I love reading about Charlie. There are so many things in there that remind me of Spencer… I think these two would get along very well. (Which is a wee bit scary!) I’d love to hear more on how you use your actions too. Mostly because my actions would not be pretty.
We obviously have a different situation here, but sleep and everything related to it is a huge struggle for us.
Also, we have found that reward charts don’t work for us. (Nor does the removal of toys and privileges.) I’m curious how the second attempt goes for you! Maybe we will try again. (Or try something similar)
Great update!
grapefruit / 4582 posts
three sounds like such a fun age! Charlie is so cute
I can’t wait to do yearly interviews with DD
blogger / pineapple / 12381 posts
@Cole: Lala likes drawing on the star more than anything else she gets from the chart, so I totally agree with you!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
I love Charlie’s cute little sayings!!
pomelo / 5321 posts
This is such a great post. I can’t believe Charlie is 3! It doesn’t seem like it’s been that long since you posted pictures of him on WB as a baby. I also love the funny things he says to you and Mr. Bee.
cherry / 161 posts
He’s such a big boy now! DS1 is 37 months old now, and is going thru a lot of the same things that Charlie is and it’s definitely been a struggle. He’s such a strong-willed kid!
I’m really interested to hear how the rewards chart thing is going. If I am correct, I suggested the coin rewards chart on Facebook, and I believe that you said you were going to try it. DS1 was really good at working towards earning his sticker for the day, and we even got to 10 stickers, so he got to choose a Spider-Man toy, which he was so excited about. Then the holidays came and he really started acting out. With the rush of the season, I kinda fell behind with handing out his daily coins, and so we took a short break from the system. I’m really hoping to get back on the wagon with it, because it seemed like DS1 really did want to try to be a good boy.
One suggestion: at first we just told DS1 that he would earn a silver star for each day if he kept all of his coins. I told him then if he got all 10 stars he would get to pick something out at the toy or book store. He didn’t seem to understand that, so I decided to tell him what specific type of toy/book he would get, and that REALLY seemed to motivate him! Knowing that he could get his first Spider-Man toy really caught his attention, and for 4 days in a row he was so well-behaved! I think having a specific reward, especially something that the child is super into, is the biggest motivator.
I’m really looking forward to your puzzle posts–I’m on the hunt for something really stimulating, since DS1 can figure out all our current puzzles in under a minute!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
He looks so grown up! I love that his favorite vegetable is a pickle. Me too, Charlie!
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@Katm558: Thanks for recommending the coin chart!! We’ve also tweaked the chart and I think it’s working nicely now. We’ll cover the reward chart as soon as Charlie earns his first prize!! He’s 3 stars away right now.
How many pieces are in DS1’s puzzles now?
coffee bean / 41 posts
I loved reading all about Charlie’s antics as a three-year-old. Have you considered rewarding him with time (ie. dates with mommy or daddy) instead of toys? It seems like Charlie thrives on your attention, and being rewarded with reading time or a special trip out might be more appealing to him!
cherry / 161 posts
@Mr. Bee–He has Melissa and Doug puzzles, including the alphabet, numbers, colored fish, a shape sorting magnet car towing puzzle, a maze, two large floor puzzles, and a magnetic peekaboo thing. He has one traditional puzzle that has 48 pieces, which takes him a bit more time. He got a pattern puzzle set for Christmas, so I’m hoping that will give him a challenge. Perhaps he just needs some more traditional wooden puzzles. I can’t wait to hear your recommendations!
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
@Cole: that’s actually similar to something we’ve been meaning to implement that dr tom suggested to us. he said to write down every single positive thing that charlie does on a huge sheet of paper. kids love when you write words, and that is a visual affirmation of things he should be doing. we’re definitely going to implement that soon!
@Mrs. Paintbrush: the reward chart seems to be working better the second time around. he said he wanted a guitar, and i had one i purchased off gilt groupe a long time ago. we put a picture of the guitar on his reward chart, but that wasn’t enough to entice him the first time we gave it a go. this time we actually showed him the guitar and put it on top of a bookcase. we have a post on how it’s been going coming up…. it’s been really interesting! check out my comment above to cole re: the positive affirmation log…. maybe that might help with spencer? or since he loves taekwondo so much, that could be his reward?
@elizabeth: we tried trips as promises like going to chuck e cheese, the zoo, etc. but that didn’t work either. the past 4 days he’s been exceptionally well-behaved though, so maybe all the changes we’ve made have had a big impact!
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
@Katm558: i think the m&d alphabet/colors/etc puzzles are probably too easy at your son’s age now. we have about 10 jigsaw puzzles, and charlie usually goes through most of them in a day. he can do a 48 piece puzzle by himself, and he needs a little bit of help with his 63 piece puzzle. but his favorite puzzle is still his gruffalo puzzle which comes with 4 puzzles that range in 12-24 pieces. it’s so easy for him to do, but he does it everyday. i think it boosts his confidence, and he just loves the gruffalo.
maybe get some jigsaw puzzles with themes that your lo loves? we also have several thomas puzzles.