To sleep train or not to sleep train, that is the question. Baby T has many attributes. He smiles and laughs often. He loves to crawl and is infinitely curious. He eats anything and everything in sight. But Baby T is not, nor has he ever been, a good sleeper.
Not being a good sleeper seems like no big deal — at first. After ten months of not sleeping well, Baby T’s inability to sleep has become a big deal. I’m a zombie. I’ve become a klutz, a grump, absent-minded and dim-witted. On top of all that, I’ve nearly emptied my meager checking account between buying lattes from the Starbucks located directly below my office, and purchasing make-up promising to make me look years younger, and more importantly, somewhat awake.
Still, I wasn’t willing to let Baby T cry it out. There were a few reasons. One was we’re living in a house with another mom and two kids who need to sleep. My first instinct is to hush him so others don’t wake up too. Another reason is I feel guilty enough that I haven’t managed to keep Baby T’s dad around. Hearing him cry makes me feel that much more like an unfit mom. Listening to a crying baby and not doing anything about it just seems cruel. In the words of William Shakespeare in Macbeth:
“Sleep that knits up the raveled sleave of care
The death of each day’s life, sore labour’s bath
Balm of hurt minds, great nature’s second course,
Chief nourisher in life’s feast.”
And without dear, sweet sleep we are reduced to just muddling through the day, in a survival mode. It’s occurred to me that my lack of sleep may in fact mean I’m missing being fully present and really enjoying Baby T’s first year. Other times I arrive at a destination and get out of my truck when I realize I don’t remember actually driving there.
I’d been struggling with whether to sleep train or not for a long time. As soon as I mustered up the energy and courage to try sleep training, something would happen. Baby T would get sick and then I would get sick and then we would go on vacation. There always seemed to be a reason to delay sleep training, not least of all that I wasn’t particularly eager to spend a night listening to my sweet baby cry.
But the time has finally come where I feel that I just have to get both Baby T and myself sleeping through the night. It started yesterday when I was running with a friend after work. There was a chain link fence in front of us. I completely miscalculated how high I had to jump and my toe caught the chain, which I fell onto and badly cut and bruised the entire shin on my right leg. It wasn’t that I didn’t see the chain; I did. It was just that I saw double of the chain – everything is a bit blurred these days, especially when I run. As I hobbled back to my friend’s house, my friend, who by occupation is a therapist, asked me how I was feeling. I told her it hurt and I was feeling like I just wanted to get a decent night of sleep. She paraphrased and said, so you’re saying you’re tired. Yep, she nailed it – I was exhausted. She asked what I could do about it. Sleep training seemed like the only reasonable answer.
Then today Baby T had a wellness check-up at his pediatrician’s office. I asked him about whether Baby T should be sleeping through the night. He hesitated at this. He told me that physically Baby T no longer needed the calories from eating during the night. He then asked me where Baby T was sleeping. When I replied that Baby T sleeps in his crib in his nursery, he thought sleeping through the night would be a good goal to work toward. Our pediatrician cautioned that getting a baby to sleep through the night is easier said than done. His advice – be strong and prepare for sleep training as you would prepare for any big endurance undertaking like running a marathon or taking the bar exam. Buy ear plugs. Download inspirational music. Enlist friends on stand by to call at all hours of the night. But whatever you do, my pediatrician warned, once you venture down the path you must continue. He told me that any time I falter, I will start at ground zero again.
It’s with great trepidation that I’ve officially decided to start sleep training. . . tomorrow that is. But first one more night of the usual middle of the night bottle feedings and rocking my baby back to sleep.
Has anyone else made the decision to sleep training? Did it work, and if so, how long did it take? Any advice for a first-timer mom?
GOLD / squash / 13464 posts
It sounds like your situation absolutely calls for sleep training. While it will be tough for a few days I think you will be so happy you did it! Good luck!!
cherry / 187 posts
Ugh. That is really tough. I was lucky enough to not have to sleep train. Have you also paid attention to his naps during the day? That can definitely affect night time sleeping. We try to keep our daughter on as regular a schedule as we can (which can be a pain for US wanting to do anything honestly, but we feel it’s worth it for a happy, sleeping baby).
clementine / 889 posts
I totally get not wanting to hear your LO cry. I hate it. It breaks my heart. But typically sleep training lasts a few days. When you think about being exhausted, groggy, forgetful, lethargic, etc… for TEN MONTHS compared with a few days of sleep training, is there any question of the need to sleep train? Think about how much more energetic, present, and happy you will be once you and your son are sleeping better. And think about the benefits for him too. It will be hard, but it will also be totally worth it. I have yet to meet a mom (including myself) who sleep trained and wished she hadn’t.
Also, I’m a child of divorced parents and making decisions for your child out of guilt for him not having a present father will not to him any favors. I’m not trying to criticize, I know I’m not in your shoes, but it is something to be mindful of. My parents gave into me a lot, and my step siblings are downright spoiled and ungrateful because my stepmom felt so guilty for leaving their dad. Just something to be mindful of.
blogger / pomelo / 5400 posts
I struggled with this question, too (phrased the same way — see under your post!) His sleep improved on its own around your LO’s age to just one waking. Then he STTN for a week — until we moved and it went to crap again
And it took two more months for it to happen again. But now he’s back to STTN. It only took him 13 months. Yawn.
Anyway, I am not anti-CIO, but the times I half-heartedly attempted it he just would cry forever. I just didn’t have the stamina. But I don’t think I ever felt as sleep-deprived as you, either … so it sounds like it will be worth it for you in the long run.
GOLD / cherry / 182 posts
@mrstilly: Thank you for your comments. I had a similar conversation with my doctor, and he reminded me that as parents we must do many difficult things that are in the best interest of our children in the long run. I am so grateful to get honest feedback – one aspect of going through a separation is not having these open dialogues with my baby’s dad, and they are so helpful.
I started sleep training last night. It was WAY less painful than I thought. I got my housemate on board and she’s completely supportive. Her children are going to sleep at their dad’s house for as long as it takes to get him sleep trained – and their dad is completely supportive of having the kids too. It feels good to have support and working on this together.
GOLD / cherry / 182 posts
@tipperella: Yes! I started with strict wake up times and eating times because napping is harder to control. But now he goes down for a nap, whether he actually falls asleep or not. Being rigid about a schedule is tough on the rest of your life, but I agree it’s worth the trade-off.
GOLD / cherry / 182 posts
@Mrs. Yoyo: Oops, I didn’t mean to use your same title. I know what you mean about trying and not having it work. Last night was the first night, and it went the best it ever has. He cried himself back to sleep each time he woke up, and he woke up like 4 times. Fingers crossed that we’re all on our way to sleeping better!
blogger / pomelo / 5400 posts
@Ms. Fairy Wings: oh, no worries! Bound to happen eventually!
pomelo / 5178 posts
@Ms. Fairy Wings: Good luck! I hope this is the beginning of more sleep for everyone!
guest
Hi Ms. Fairy Wings. I am a mom to a 8-month old boy. I sleep train my baby when he was 4 months old for the same reason, I couldn’t function without a decent uninterrupted sleep. I know from a get-go cry it out method is for him. My case is atypical. he would cry for 15 mins when I put him down. but he cried for 15 mins for two-months before he finally cave to the idea of sleeping. although he cried when I put him down at 7.30 pm, he was able to sleep longer over time. between 4 to 6 months old, he would only wake up once at 3 am for in the middle of the night feeding (versus 2 to 3x). at 6 months old, my pediatrician gave a green light to drop that night feeding. I worried I may need to do sleep train phase 2 but i didn’t have to. He just naturally sleep to 4, 5 and eventually 6 am. recently, when I put him down, he would cry for like 1 minute but after I pat him for a few seconds, he would self-soothe and fall asleep on his own. it is totally worth it despite 2 months of 15 mins cry every night. I feel like a normal working person again. The key is consistency in bed time routine and how you would react when he cries should you go with cry it out method. Good luck
clementine / 889 posts
@Ms. Fairy Wings: I can’t imagine being a single parent and not having DH to talk things through with. I’m so glad that you have support and help with the sleep training. The first two nights I cried. I’m glad it’s goin well too.
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
I just started this journey with my son, but we’re not fully night weaning yet. He is 6 months.
If I didn’t have dh to help with night and morning wakings- I would definitely have to sleep train too!! Ugh cannot imagine how tired you are. But I totally understand your hesitations.
We’ve been using the extinction method after the Ferber method didn’t work. It’s soo hard but his sleep has drastically improved and there is a lot less crying, it’s been nearly two weeks and it’s not perfect yet, but we’ve made progress and it’s getting easier.
I do think your ped is right about consistency. If I feel my baby really does need me, I go to him. It is usually a setback but I won’t live with any regrets. Like last night, he banged his head on his crib and I couldn’t not go in to make sure he was okay!!
So try your best to be consistent, but allow yourself to stay true to your mommy heart. Only YOU know what’s best for your son, no book, friend, dr or even hellobee can tell you what you know about you and your son,
Good luck and we’re here to support you!!
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
We started really early using the Moms on Call method. He was just a couple weeks old and we moved him to his own room, arms tightly swaddled, with a white noise machine. It helped that we couldn’t hear his little noises at night anymore so we weren’t responding to sleep noises. When he actually needed us to respond, we could hear him. That helped him become an awesome sleeper. But at 3.5m his naps went horribly bad so I did start to CIO for naps. I started by associating a lovey with soothing by holding it whenever we nursed. The lovey worked really well and still does – now that we’ve hit 8m and he’s suddenly developed separation anxiety when I leave him at night!
persimmon / 1329 posts
I started a little bit before my son turned 6 mos out of pure exhaustion. I just couldn’t do it anymore–the constant feeding and rocking every 30 mins to an hr. I kept delaying it because I was nervous about him screaming and pissing off our neighbros as we live in an apt. But to be honest, the first night was bad (27 mins of crying, but afterwards it got better and by day 4 he was going down with little to no crying. Like Coco Bee, the Ferber Method didn’t work with our LO. He would get even more loud and excitable when I went to check in. The only thing that did it for us was the Extinction Method by Dr. Weissbluth. I think the key is being consistent no matter what you end up doing. Good luck!
guest
WoW, what a timely post for me. I started sleep training my 10 month old last night. Just like you, I’ve been in a daze since the wee one was born and every time I tried to train something would happen to delay it(vacation, evening engagement, etc.)
When LB was born, I didn’t know what I was going to do regarding sleeping arrangements and my husband and I just got into the habit of having her fall asleep in our bed. After a few months, I was ready for her to have her own bed and room, BUT my husband was not (he can’t stand to hear his baby cry). He finally agreed to it last night after I told him that once she can start calling out “mom” and “dad” it would be way harder for us to let her cry herself to sleep.
Last night she cried non-stop for about 45 minutes and then off-and-on for another 45 minutes. She slept through most of the night (I still nursed her back to sleep a couple of times) but she seemed to stay asleep better than usual. Tonight she cried for about 15 minutes and then fell asleep within 35 minutes. I’m keeping my fingers crossed.
All my friends have used the cry it out method and they swear that by the 4th night, the baby will no longer cry. So far so good!
apricot / 370 posts
one of the best gifts you can give your child, is the ability to let him/her self soothe and fall asleep on their own. my friend told me that years of her parents coddling her and not letting her figure out how to self soothe, led to a variety of sleeping problems as an adult. maybe an extreme case but something to think about.
GOLD / cherry / 182 posts
@kakimochi: Thank you for reminding this. I do think this is one example of how good parenting requires us to do some things that make our child feel uncomfortable in the moment but are good in the long run. Ahh, I’m learning so much about love and parenting, but oh there is so much to learn!
guest
I have a 5 month old boy who was sleeping through the night then 2 weeks ago he got his first fever & cold so now he’s waking every 1.5 hours to nurse. We co-sleep and I just downloaded the No Cry Sleep Solution and I have started the process to get him to sleep through the night again & move him into his room/crib. I’m in it for the long haul but I hope we get through it so he develops great sleeping habits without having to cry himself to exhaustion. I really like NCSS’s approach. There is a lot of info and you have to figure out a plan that will work for you but thank goodness there are many options to choose from in her book. Best of Luck to you Momma. Solidarity!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
Good luck with sleep training!
GOLD / cherry / 182 posts
@ Moni Cabradnan – Yep, solidarity will get us through! It’s so hard when you get your lil one sleeping and then along comes a cold, a trip or a new tooth or two. Baby T is crying right now when he should be taking his mid-day nap. Sleep training is hard, but last night I slept for 8 – count’ em- hours straight and feel amazing today, so I know it’s worth it! Good luck to you too!
GOLD / cherry / 182 posts
@Leialou: Thanks! All the support is much appreciated:)
GOLD / grape / 85 posts
@ms. fairy wings: I totally know how you feel about having your baby cry it out. When Emmett was being sleep-trained, it really felt like I was having an anxiety attack hearing my baby so distressed. But at the end of it all, I think it really is what’s best for them, especially if you do it in a way that’s best for you & your baby. For me, I was only comfortable letting him CIO for 20-30 minutes before I went in, picked him up, comforted him until he calmed down (5ish minutes) and put him back down. We did this routine over and over again and it took him about 5 months to finally get it. Best wishes to you and your LO!!
guest
NEVER thought we would CIO….10.5 months later, and after a near concussion from walking into a door in a sleep-deprived stupor, I changed my tune. We went ahead and let her cry it out. It was horrible. No, HORRIBLE!!! I just continuously reminded myself, “She’s clean, healthy, fed and loved. She’s just mad.” One week later, she was sleeping through the night. Worth every tear we both shed during that week of hell. Good luck! You can do it too!