In my short time as a parent, I have slowly begun to realize that every week, every month, every stage of development arrives with its own “Everest”: a mountain of a challenge that must be climbed. In the midst of the upward push, it feels OH SO DAUNTING. I find myself researching the heck out of the ‘best’ way to make it to the top, and best of all, the downhill half. And when I reach the pinnacle, I often don’t realize I have until I am happily on the other side of it!
The current Everest at the Milk home is nap time. Oh, nap time! Naps are proving to be one of the most mentally exhausting ventures for us. I am stuck in a ‘purposeful parenting’ limbo wherein I want to raise a flexible, adaptable person who can go with the flow and find comfort in any situation, but I also want my kid to NAP! In my thinking, raising this kind of flexible kid means trying now to have an adaptive, non-regimented schedule for seven-month old Baby Milk, William. We have routines, sure – including a very specific bedtime one. But we try ever so hard to follow cues and, rather than set our day around Will’s “schedule,” we think through what we want to accomplish and ensure we have a method for how to meet Will’s basic needs – food, love and sleep.
However, it is that last need – sleep – that I find most parents rest in two camps. On one side, there are families that plan their days and activities around ensuring that their child can follow his routine and schedule for sleeping – during the day and at night. We actually are in this camp for bedtime. We, very purposefully, ensure that Will’s bedtime is paramount and we can follow his routines, albeit with some adjustments if we are traveling or it’s a holiday or special event. On the other side, some families give less attention to following a specific ‘schedule’ and know that their child will get their needs met while on-the-go.
We tend to fall on ‘adaptive’ side for daytime sleep. For the majority of Will’s seven months of life, that has felt right. When I was on maternity leave, I often planned my day around his big, midday nap and he would take that nap ‘on-the-go’ and this translated to daily adventures. Woohoo! We tended to follow this schedule on the weekends, after I transitioned back to work, which, again, resulted in the ability to venture out and go shopping, out to eat, or whatever.
And then – bam! William may have hit the four-month-sleep regression, but it was something at about six months that hit us like a DOOZY. I’m pretty sure it was teething tied into developmental leaps (he started crawling one week after he turned seven months), but we had a solid month of 2-5 wake-ups per night. Nap time took a hit too- what was a consistent three 45-90 minute naps became ‘maybe he’ll pass out from exhaustion before noon and sleep for thirty minutes.’
Nighttime sleep has been better these past ten days or so (fingers crossed I don’t jinx myself by sharing that!), but naps are still a daily challenge. I’m beginning to wonder if we need to pull away from our ‘adaptive’ approach and consider protecting his daily sleep as much as we do his nights.
Here are the steps we’ve taken to try to help Will nap:
- Spoke to our pediatrician about the short length of Will’s naps. He asked about Will’s demeanor with the abbreviated naps (still happy and very chill) and noted that some children have lower sleep needs. As long as he’s growing, healthy and joyful, we shouldn’t be overly concerned. Undeterred, we endeavored to try to help Will sleep for longer during the day.
- Reviewed and read tips from parents who have come before us.
- Some of my favorites: Nap Training, Dealing with Short Naps, Naps at Six Months , and these two swarms on how much sleep different babies get and transitioning naps.
- Asked daycare their routines for naps, as he seems to do better (often taking two hour long afternoon naps!) there.
- Adjusted our routine to fit what daycare shared: put him in a sleep sack, place him in his pack n’ play awake, and soothe him if he cries but immediately place him back when calm.
- Aligned bedtime to naptime. We began napping him in his crib when at home, following his nighttime ‘cues’ – white noise, sleep sack, bottle – and generally trying to show him that daytime sleep is similar to nighttime sleep.
- Let him ‘fuss it out’. We let him fuss a bit when he inevitably wakes up after 20-30 minutes to see if he can calm himself to transition to the next sleep cycle, or as he attempts to fall asleep.
These all seem to work…about half the time. It also meant that Mr. Milk and I spent several Saturdays just trying to get our little guy to sleep. It put us both in horrible moods and, at the end of the day, we felt that we hadn’t been able to enjoy our free time with our son and what was usually a joy became a chore.
Currently, we’re in the stage of ‘waiting it out’ and recognizing that any sleep, whenever it happens and wherever it happens, is good sleep. We try to follow any signs of tiredness and help Will sleep when he rubs his eyes or gets the crankies, but if we find ourselves focusing too much on trying to help him sleep (and thus, getting extremely frustrated by doing so), we take a step back and regroup. If we’re out and about, this means abandoning the bouncing, ‘shush’-ing, bottle-pushing we might be doing and instead focusing on pointing out the interesting sights around us or being goofy with our son to coax out a giggle. If we’re at home, we pull him out of his pack n’ play and engage with him with some toys and songs.
This method is feeling so much better, mentally and emotionally, but, of course, Will still is not a consistent napper, and it stresses out our caregivers from time to time. I oscillate between being very chill and zen about it all…and giving in to my WHY WON’T HE SLEEP furies.
Any advice for napping we haven’t tried? Anyone out there successfully ‘wait out’ a kid who eventually became a great napper? Give me hope, please!
blogger / nectarine / 2043 posts
Oh, he sounds exactly like my kiddo at that age. Naps were a mess for us until she hit about 10 months and was solidly in the 2 nap stage. Until then, she would mostly catnap. The only way to get anything more than 45 minutes was to hold her, and even that was a rarity. Although I am a very routine/structure person, when it came to naps, I did whatever worked to get her to sleep. Even now (she’s almost 22 months), we cuddle and rock her a little bit before naps out of habit, though she doesn’t really need it anymore.
What helped me a lot is anticipating when she would be likely to want to sleep. I read the 90 Minute Solution book when she was still an infant, and realized through observation that 90 minute cycles are about average for all of us, adults included. At 6-7 months, the maximum amount of time kids should be awake between sleep is 2-3 hours (this is a helpful chart if you haven’t seen it – https://docs.google.com/document/d/11GHo4keUb2TVJUlSL1kD6HQcEgaNFBmzoQoOzcpcyas/edit?hl=en&authkey=CPXE1bsO&pli=1). So once she was awake for the day, I would average out when she would need to nap in those intervals, and depending on how long she napped, I’d count the next interval from the time she woke up, etc. It seemed to hold pretty true for the most part. And honestly, we would rock her or make sure we were driving so she would dose off in those general time frames. As they get older, their sleep will start to consolidate and they will take longer naps. For us that started to happen around 9-10 months and after that, she became a completely independent sleeper for naps (she always was for nighttime, thankfully) who now naps a solid 2 hours on 1 nap. My theory has always been that napping isn’t forever, so I wasn’t as worried about the “bad” habits like rocking and holding. I wanted her to be rested, and she’s a low sleep needs kid in general (her nighttime is on the lowest end of averages for her age, usually somewhat below even) so whatever rest I could facilitate, I was happy to.
The best method for you is going to be one that keeps everyone as sane as possible. I remind myself that things get better as they get older, though it is hard to remember that in the moment. Good luck!
guest
Right there with you! My son is the same age and is an ok napper. I’ll be checking back to see what advice people have for sure! Good luck to you!
blogger / nectarine / 2043 posts
One other thing to add is that my kid got really excited by all the stimulation around her, especially at that age, so we did our best to minimize things she could stare at (put away all the toys, covered her with a blanket if we were out, etc. It’s such a huge age for exploration that sleep gets in the way!
nectarine / 2821 posts
I totally have that why won’t he sleep furies! It’s one of those things I have to take a step back when I keep trying over and over to put him down for a nap I know he needs but is fighting!!
blogger / nectarine / 2010 posts
3.5-5.5 months was a nightmare with my first. He slept well at night but naps OMG the WORST! He napped for 7minutes. Seven!! Then one day he napped for an hour. Then a little more. And then he became a great napper. He napped really well until one month past three. So there’s hope. I tried everytging but what finally worked was accepting that naps sucked and following his sleepy signs. I let him fuss, swaddled and made it similar to bedtime as soon as he yawned. I think it was a sleep regression.
papaya / 10343 posts
I feel like some kids just need more structure to sleep. My LO has generally been a fabulous napper— so long as we give her what she needs. Which used to be me holding her/rocking her for all naps and now consists of sleeping only in her crib at home with our black out shades and white noise on and after doing her nap routine of sleep sack and song and then getting put down. No matter how tired she is she never ever passes out in the car or while being worn or while being held anywhere other than in her bedroom. I think if we tried to make her sleep on the go… she just wouldn’t sleep. And it seems like Will may be similar since he naps great at daycare where there is a routine and structure. Seems like you just nee to decide what is more important– going about your life, or getting your kid to sleep regularly! There is no wrong answer, I’m sure he’ll be fine either way. But I think a lot of kids just aren’t capable of being “sleep anywhere” babies once they are a little older.
guest
YES!!! I totally relate to what you’re saying. Naps took so much of my energy for so long until I finally had to put my fears of creating “bad habits” aside and just focus on doing what worked. I actually wrote a post on my blog last week detailing the many stages of Bea’s nap evolution because suddenly, no thanks to me, she has just grown into taking two long naps each day. I had my doubts about a wait-and-see approach, but it felt so much better than trying to force it, and I’m over the moon that the situation resolved itself.
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
we nap trained both kids. before that they were horrible cat nappers, but both went on to become the best nappers at their daycare. they usually took 3-4 hour naps on weekends. we nap trained charlie at 4 1/2 months and Olive at 8 months. it was life changing and i’d do it again because they got so much more sleep.
with charlie we were completely schedule-bound, but olive was always go with the flow since she was a second child. i think they both sleep similarly well… olive probably better.
blogger / apricot / 310 posts
@Mrs. Carrot: This is great thank you! And thanks for that link! I think you’re completely right with your final note – needed that
@junebugsmama: YES exactly! I get too far in the zone of trying to force him to sleep, which has worked exactly never. lol
@Mrs. Stroller: oh man, that seven minute nap sounds killer! i am hoping this two-month period is a regression and we’ll come out of it. he’ll do decent 1 hour+ naps about two or three times a week, (once a day), so I harbor some hope!
@Mae: all very good points! I think Will is very much a kid who loves movement to help him sleep, so car / stroller naps are his jam. He just often finds something stimulating to see when he tries to transition sleep cycles on those kinds of naps! I think we’ll buckle down a few weekends and focus on structure and see what happens -thank you!
@Sarah: that’s great news and gives me such hope – thank you!!!
@Mrs. Bee: I had just re-read your post on nap training Olive and was all set to really try it this weekend – and then Will got a pretty bad cold and needing to nap upright stopped us. Once he recovers, though, I am going to sit and work out a plan for helping Will get his naps set. They already let him fuss it out at daycare, so that will help. I think we just need to figure out our rules – like, at night, we re-evaluate every five minutes to assess if he’s fussing or full on crying/needs us. We need something similar for naps…and I think we need a video monitor to help us see what exactly is happening as he goes down! Just have to convince the other half to get on board with that plan…
guest
I don’t have any answers – I have a terrible napper who occasionally has periods of good naps – but I wanted to thank you so much for a post that doesn’t just lay out “the answers” and acknowledges the constant self-doubt and questioning that is parenting. It’s nice to read about someone else who is just working through the processes. Thanks!
guest
Thanks for sharing your naptime “Everest”! It’s incredible to see just how different one baby’s sleepy needs can differ from another’s. I work as a Newborn Care Specialist and no two babies are ever the same when it comes to sleeping, eating, soothing, smiling or diapering!