There’s a new player in the breast pump field! Meet the Spectra line of pumps. It’s not an Ameda and it’s not a Medela, but it’s still an awesome pump that can totally run with these big names.
Above: The Spectra S2 breast pump.
When the Trikester was born, I picked an Ameda double electric, and although fine, the motor died on me (twice!) and I had to have replacements over-nighted from the manufacturer. With the arrival of baby #2, I was able to get another free breast pump, so in selecting one I decided to throw caution to the wind and choose something I’d never heard of, even though it had very few reviews (my options were limited to those offered by the durable medical equipment supplier preferred by my insurance company).
My choice? The Spectra S2. Spectra is relatively new to the US market. From what I can tell, they’re based in Australia (the YouTube reviews I could find sported that awesome Aussie accent). The S2 is a double electric, closed system. It’s billed as a “hospital grade” pump, which I’m assuming refers to quality of the motor (it’s rated for 1500 hours). It has a letdown mode and an expression mode – settings that mimic the change in a baby’s sucking pattern during a nursing session. My letdown is crazy immediate, so I can’t comment on how well that setting works – I just keep the pump in expression mode. Additionally, it allows you to change both the frequency and strength of the suction. The pump easily converts from a double to single – there’s a built in adapter that you use to cap over one of the tubing connectors.
The stock valves on the collection kit that came with the pump were the duck-bill variety, but when I purchased a spare set from their web site to keep at work, I received the kind with the little rubber disk. The backflow preventers were also different – easier to assemble than what came with the pump, so if you have any reason to buy a second set of pump parts it might be a slight upgrade.
I’ve been using the pump for five months now, and I’m really happy with it. Here are the major pros and cons, if you’re interested in checking it out yourself.
Pros:
- It has a built-in timer. This might not seem like a huge deal, but it’s so much easier than having to remember my phone every time I pump. It’s the feature I appreciate the most.
- It has a nightlight. I haven’t used it a ton, but I was stuck pumping in a public bathroom recently, and the lights automatically shut off once they didn’t sense movement. I turned my pump light on, and it wasn’t quite so dark.
- It’s a closed system so I don’t ever have to wash the tubing.
- It’s relatively quiet, or at least more so than my previous pump. It’s still annoying enough to have to cover it with a pillow when we’re watching TV, but it’s an improvement.
Cons:
- There’s no place to set down bottles once they’re attached to the pump. There’s a depression in the back of the pump to rest one bottle, but it’s not a snug fit, so when you set a bottle there it just tips over.
- The S2 model needs to be plugged in. There are certain times I’d like to pump without electricity near-by. There’s a newer model out that’s identical to the S2, but it comes with a rechargeable battery pack.
- It’s not a super popular pump (yet), so you can’t run to Target to purchase spare parts. Instead, you can buy what you’d need through their web site.
Spectra recently introduced a new model – it’s called the Spectra 9 – and it has the advantage of being completely portable – the motor and battery would fit in a large pocket. I don’t know if I’d choose this pump, as it appears less heavy duty, but as I was attempting to empty the dishwasher this morning AND pump simultaneously, I can definitely see some advantages to portability.
One last reason to love this company? They’re a little cheeky. You can buy both a breast pump that looks like an actual boob (it’s the Dew model), and an S2 from the Bling Collection — and I quote “You don’t have to be a start to pump like one.”
Above: The Spectra Dew – gotta love how the design references its purpose.
Above: The S2 all decked out in “genuine Swarovski crystals.”
Have you used a Spectra pump? What did you think? Do you mind taking risks on a less well-known brand when it’s a big purchase?
guest
For my first baby, I got the Medela Pump In Style, like everyone else. This time around, I noticed my insurance company offered the Spectra2 and found that it got positive reviews on Amazon so I went for it. I love it! I also have a quick letdown and a ton of milk so I can’t comment on whether it helps pump out more, but I’ve been very happy with it. I especially love the timer and the light. And I like that I can control both the suction and the speed. I don’t like the bottles or how the breastshield/valve thing is one piece. I think it makes it harder to clean and the plastic feels cheap to me. BUT there are ways around it! I hacked the tubing so I can use my Medela parts (shield, valve, membranes, and bottles) with it! And it doesn’t affect the closed system. If you google it, several tutorials come up. It was super easy and now I use all my Medela parts with it, which also means less washing since I have multiples!
cherry / 108 posts
I have never heard of this pump and wasn’t considering getting a new one till I read your old post just now on seeing insurance coverage for a new pump. Now I’m at work researching to get a new one! I liked my last pump (Avent double electric), but I hated that there was no car adapter and it didn’t fit well into one of those hands free pump bras which would have saved so much time at work while I do my notes. And I also had to get a replacement motor at one point. Would the flanges on the Spectra fit a hands free pump bra?
watermelon / 14467 posts
Thanks for posting this review! The Spectra is one that my insurance offers and I am considering that or the Hygiea for my second baby (in the future). I also had an Ameda and I was not impressed with it. My motor completely died after only 8 months of use (twice a day five days a week) and I had to use a backup (an older Ameda I purchased from someone my husband works with) to limp through to the end, in addition to renting a hospital-grade Ameda for a month.
guest
i just wanted to mention that I believe hospital grade means a closed system and therefore can be used by multiple users. It’s a big no-no to use a second-hand pump like a PIS or the other open-system ones out there. Even if you change the tubing and all parts, you still shouldn’t use a pump that someone else has used. Just thought I’d mention it for anyone who isn’t familiar.
blogger / apricot / 335 posts
Wow I never heard of this brand! Thanks for sharing!
guest
Just got the Spectra S1 (rechargeable version) and love it! I had a Hygeia before and love this much better. I really like the let down mode and it is so much quieter than the Hygeia.
blogger / pear / 1964 posts
@Noelle I read about those tubing hacks – I can’t say the flanges really bother me – though I agree that the neck is a little narrow for cleaning. Still haven’t perfected a method for that yet,
@Chicfro: Humm. I’m not sure. I haven’t tried it with a hands free bra – I just leave my nursing bra clipped and stuff them in there – that works fine for me – I might have to adjust them now and then, but it’s hands free enough to use my phone while I’m pumping.
@morgan – that’s great to know – probably should have looked that term up – I always wondered what it meant!
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
Having never breastfed, I’m so unfamiliar with these things, but those bedazzled things are hilarious!!!
blogger / nectarine / 2600 posts
Need to look into this more. I still have my Medela from Juliet but I needed it replaced a few times when I had the same one with Drake and wondering if a different brand would work better for me.
blogger / pear / 1964 posts
@Mrs. Cowgirl: it’s the prefect fashion accessories for every mom on the go ’cause, ya know, I always want to impress the crowd I’m pumping in front of.
blogger / pomegranate / 3044 posts
Cool! I only ever used a PISA and then a symphony rental.
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
I’ve never heard of this! But I was very happy with my Medela PISA… it lasted through two kids, and I handed it down to another mom who says it still beats out her brand new Ameda!
blogger / honeydew / 7081 posts
That boob-shaped pump is hilarious. I love it.
blogger / apricot / 349 posts
Love this review! Never heard of this brand either. I used a Medela PISA too. I loved it.