As I was putting my three year old to bed one night, she brought up a conversation about death, completely out of the blue. It went like this.
Lil’ Pizza: Why will we surely die?
Me: Because that’s just what happens to all of us.
Lil’ Pizza: Will I die?
Me: Yes, you will die.
Lil’ Pizza: Will you die?
Me: Yes.
Lil’ Pizza: Appah? (dad in Korean)
Me: Yes, Appah will die.
Lil’ Pizza: Gracie too?
Me: Yes, we will all die.
Lil’ Pizza: What will you say when I die?
Me: Well, I will be so sad.
Lil’ Pizza: Why?
Me: Because I won’t see you anymore…until I can see you in heaven.
Lil’ Pizza: Why? (tears start rolling down her face)
Me: That’s just what happens when you die.
Lil’ Pizza: Until I see you in heaven? (now I hear some sniffling)
Me: But don’t worry. You will not die soon and I will not die soon and Appah and Gracie will not die soon.
Lil’ Pizza: Will I see you in the morning?
Me: Yes.
Then Lil’ Pizza proceeded to smile and talk about how happy she was to be sleeping with her Hello Kitty sleeping bag. You could imagine I let out a big sigh of relief when that conversation was over. I wasn’t completely satisfied with what I said, but I know I will have more opportunities in the future to say things differently as Lil’ Pizza’s curiosity grows and when she personally is impacted by the death of a loved one.
This conversation with Lil’ Pizza had me thinking about the conversations that I have had with children at the hospital about the death of a loved one, whether it was the loss of their sibling, parent, or grandparent.
Here are some things to keep in mind when talking to your child about the death of a loved one:
1. The conversation will be ongoing and will continue to evolve as they grow older. It is rarely a one time conversation, especially if it was the death of a significant person in their life.
2. Young children will often ask the same questions, which may require a lot of repeating explanations. For example, preschool age children who don’t see death as a permanent state may ask repeatedly, when the person is coming back.
3. Children can show deep sadness and then completely shift gears, change the conversation, or just want to play soon after. It is completely normal.
4. Read your child’s cues. If she seems disengaged and not interested in listening, try again later. It might be too much for them at the time.
5. Be short, simple, and honest. As difficult as it is, use words “dead” and “dying” so as not to lead to misconceptions. For example, a child told that the person is “sleeping” may fear going to bed.
6. Your child might not be ready to talk much or ask questions just yet. Simply letting your child know you are available to talk whenever they want about the death is so important.
7. Let your child know that it is a difficult time for everyone and it is a time of feeling very sad. Let them know that there will be a lot of people around them that will feel this way and that it is okay to cry and feel sad too.
8. It may be helpful to start by asking your child what they know of the death first and then elaborate or clarify from there.
9. Let young children express themselves through pretend play. You may discover some misconceptions about their understanding of the death during their play.
10. It’s okay to say you don’t know all the answers. You can let them know that you need some time to think about something they asked and get back to them. You can also let them know that you don’t know but you are working to figure it out.
. . . . .
I also wanted to mention a few books that I have used that I thought were great resources to use with children experiencing a loss of a loved one.
How I Feel: A Coloring Book for Grieving Children (Age 3-8) – This coloring book explores all the different feelings that children may face when a loved one dies. I think this is important to talk about with children because it gives them permission to feel the way they are feeling.
The Invisible String (Age 3-8) – The Invisible String is a comforting story about two siblings who learn that everyone has an invisible string that connects them to everyone they love…anywhere, anytime. Not only is this a great book to read with a child who lost a loved one, but also for a child who is dealing with separation anxiety (i.e. the start of school, divorce, separation).
When Dinosaurs Die: A Guide to Understanding Death (Age 4-8) – I thought this was an excellent resource. Instead of a story, it is written as a question and answer book and answers questions such as, “why does someone die? and “what does dead mean?”
The Goodbye Book (Age 3-6) – I love books by Todd Parr because his books are simple and right on point. It talks about the difficulties of saying goodbye to someone. I like how this book ends because it reassures the reader that there is always someone that loves them.
. . . . .
When I had that conversation about death with my three year old, I realized that it was only the beginning of many difficult conversations that I will have with my girls as they grow up and face the world. It’s terrifying, but I think as long as we speak from the heart and express our love to them, we got most of it right.
hostess / wonderful persimmon / 25556 posts
Death is such a hard topic with kids. My daughter likes to talk about it but obviously has no idea what she is talking about as she told us this morning at the breakfast table that one of her friends at daycare is dead (she’s not).
She does like to ask where “the other Thumper” is (we used to have two dogs and one passed away when she was 6 months old) and where people in some pictures are (like her Great Gram). Tough topic for a 3 year old to understand!
blogger / kiwi / 675 posts
This is such a hard topic and my daughter asks a lot of questions on this topic…I approach it from a religious stand point but do find it very difficult to talk about, I always want to lead her in the right direction and this is so open ended…thanks for your thoughts!
apricot / 309 posts
We recently got a book called “Ida, always” which tells the story of two polar bears who live in a zoo. Ida gets sick and the zookeeper explains to Gus what happens. It’s a very sweet and poignant picture book – the upshot is that even when Ida is gone, she’ll always be with him because he will remember her.
It makes me want to cry whenever I read the book, but I think it does a good job of explaining death in a way that kids understand. And without being too scary. I’d definitely recommend it.
pea / 15 posts
Thanks for the tips! I always feel like I’m caught off guard when my older two ask profound questions. I will definitely be looking for those books. I love that there are so many resources to help explain these difficult things instead of feeling like I have to give the “right” answer on my own.
blogger / apricot / 431 posts
@Mrs. Palette: There is a short book called Water Bugs and Dragonflies that a Christian pastor wrote that can help answer some of the difficult questions too. The story can actually be found easily online if you Google it. I forgot to mention it but it’s a beautiful story!
blogger / apricot / 431 posts
@lemong: I’m definitely going to look for that book. Sounds like a beautiful story!
blogger / apricot / 431 posts
@mamasong: I totally agree. There are so many wonderful resources out there for us for soany difficult topics. I just didn’t realize that these kinds of questions would come up so soon!
guest
So heartbreaking and so sweet. You’re an amazing mother
blogger / apricot / 431 posts
@lemong: so I borrowed the book Ida, Always. I choke up everytime I read it. I’ve had to read it many times for my daughter because she likes it. She did get all emotional about it for one of the readings. It’s such a beautiful story. Thanks for sharing!