Adapted from a post originally written in November 2012, when Little C was 5.5 months old.
The decision had been a long time in the making. Tears had been shed, sleep had been lost, but deep down, I knew it was time.
Breastfeeding was something I knew I wanted to do before I was even pregnant. I looked forward to bonding with Little C as he nursed, being not only his caregiver but his provider of the best possible nourishment a baby could get. I imagined serene images of a snuggly baby boy nuzzled up at my breast, both of us calm as we settled down for him to peacefully nurse at my breast.
We got off to a bumpy start. Little C struggled at mastering the latch, and by the time he got the hang of it, he was three weeks old, and I had bloody, scabbed nipples and a broken spirit from a lack of sleep and an intense, painful bout of mastitis. Simultaneously, I caught a vicious stomach bug, and I spent the next week barely able to stomach any food, chained to the commode with a nursing baby at my breast. Struggling to stay fed and hydrated, I insisted on forging ahead in breastfeeding, and within less than a month, I had lost nearly all of my pregnancy pounds.
After those rough early weeks, Little C mastered the latch, my nipples began healing (thanks to Newman’s Nipple Cream – the magical salve that restored my faith in nursing), and we fell into a good rhythm. I was ensuring that Little C’s needs were being met, feeding him every few hours, and forging my way into motherhood. I was so concerned about tending to Little C that in all honesty, I was not doing the best job taking care of myself.
I have always been a light eater, often eating lots of small meals and snacks throughout the day. Once Little C was born, I found myself skipping meals, because I would be too busy, or I would forget, or we’d be out for a walk and C would fall asleep, and I wouldn’t want to wake him to go in for lunch. Staying hydrated has never been my strong suit, and somehow my mind never connected with the need to drink as I nursed Little C. I knew rationally that I should be eating and drinking more if I wanted to continue to feed myself and him, but my appetite wasn’t there (especially after my stomach bug) and no matter how much I tried, I couldn’t seem to stay on top of my own needs while tending to C, our puppy, our household and everyday life.
As the scale dipped lower and lower, flying past my pre-pregnancy weight, and then even past my high school graduation weight, I noticed my supply starting to dip. Little C was eating more and more regularly, and by the end of the day, he was so fussy that he wouldn’t even latch at my breast. I started pumping so we could give him a bottle at bedtime, and soon, I had to pump twice (and sometimes three times) to get enough for that one bottle. In my mind, supplementing with formula was out of the question. And still, his nursing needs during the day were seeming to increase, rather than him becoming more efficient and nursing less frequently, as the books said he would.
My lack of sleep (from staying up later in the night to pump for the next night’s bottle, plus an early a.m. nursing session) combined with the stress and guilt didn’t help my supply. Then at four months, Little C hit a growth spurt, a sleep regression and got two teeth, all in the span of a couple weeks. On top of all of that, I had several painful plugged ducts and caught a massive cold which basically put the nail in the coffin when regarding my supply. No amount of Mother’s Milk Tea, oatmeal, lactation cookies, increased food and hydration, extra pumping or anything else I tried seemed to help.
Finally one morning when Little C was about five months old, after nursing as we usually did, I played with him for a bit, and as he had been for a week or so, he became crabby and was showing hunger signs very soon after nursing.
We had a sample tub of Similac in the house from an event I had attended, and despite my single-minded determination to nurse exclusively, I had kept it in the back of our pantry, in case of an emergency. Ironically, there was no emergency – just the emergence of a crabby baby who shouldn’t be hungry yet, and nothing else I tried seemed to make him happy.
I offered the bottle of formula, and he took four ounces immediately. He guzzled them. No taste confusion, no bottle troubles, no problems. If anything, after that bottle, he seemed happier to me than he had in weeks, and the addition of formula into his world was no big deal to him.
It was a huge deal to me.
I fed him, and I cried, partially because I felt guilty not to have tried this sooner and partially because I knew that I did not reach my original goal of breastfeeding without supplementing with formula for at least six months. I cried because everything I had read touted the benefits of breast milk and decried formula as second-rate food (which is grossly exaggerated, I know, but the blogosphere is rife with formula hatred). I cried because I felt like a failure, even though I knew deep down it wasn’t true.
I knew that formula would be just fine for Little C, because both of his parents were raised exclusively on formula, and we both turned out to be happy, healthy, successful adults. And I knew that the five months of exclusive breastfeeding he had would hopefully do wonders in combating future allergies and had already helped immensely in protecting him from colds and illness.
I recognized that my angst was overly exaggerated (and likely driven primarily by hormones), and what mattered most was making sure that the baby was fed, but still, the sadness lingered. I knew it was the beginning of the end – and boy was I right. As soon as I started supplementing, my body recognized quickly that demand was lower, and my supply continued to wither until we weaned completely within about a month. I also knew that there would likely be some positives peppered in with all of the negative emotions I was facing about weaning – being able to wear dresses again, not worrying about pumping and my freezer stash, eating spicy food again. More than anything though, I knew all of these positives meant nothing at the time compared to the smile on Little C’s face when he had a full tummy from that silly bottle of formula I’d put off giving for so long.
Did you have to wean before you hoped or planned? How did you handle the transition?
Weaning part 3 of 13
1. A slow wean by mrs. tictactoe2. My Breastfeeding Adventure by Mrs. Tea
3. The End of an Era: My Decision to Wean by Mrs. Confetti
4. Nursing Beyond the Second Year by Mrs. Twine
5. Our Adventures in Weaning by Mrs. Train
6. Weaning. by Mrs. Makeup
7. Weaning: Our journey by Mrs. Yoyo
8. Smile because it happened... by Mrs. Pen
9. Why I Want to Wean... and Why I Don't Want to Wean by Mrs. Bee
10. Adventures in Weaning by Mrs. Bee
11. Olive is Weaned. by Mrs. Bee
12. Weaning at Two by Mrs. Stroller
13. Weaning at 18 months by Mrs. Deer
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
I weaned at 11-months… one month short of my goal of 12-months, and I still have some regrets over it. I was so busy at work and traveling a lot for work around that time so it was hard for me to squeeze in pumping sessions during the day. She was also constantly distracted at the boob and would de-latch so often that it seemed like she was ready to wean anyway.
I keep thinking if only I stuck it out just a little longer… logically, I know formula is fine and have nothing against it, but I still can’t help feel that tinge of regret.
Once we weaned, I was sad for about 2 weeks and really missed our nursing relationship, but after that… I loved the freedom of not worrying about pumping or being nearby to feed her. For the first time in nearly a year I could come and go as I please and not worry about rushing home by a certain time. That was really nice!
GOLD / wonderful pomegranate / 28905 posts
oh sweetie, my heart cries a little for you reading this post. I know how you are feeling. The feeling of “starving” your child, no matter the reassurances other well meaning moms give you never can erase that image of your baby guzzling a bottle down after you just breastfed them. I think you made the best decision for your baby and that’s what great moms do. Good for your for persevering as long as you did but realizing your baby was more important than your desire of BFing.
grapefruit / 4717 posts
Thanks for sharing. This must have been so hard, but it sounds like it was the right decision for you. And Little C looks so happy and healthy that formula seems to be working just fine. After trouble starting with breastfeeding, we’re at 9.5 mo, and I’m already sad about thinking about weaning. I won’t miss pumping at work, though!
persimmon / 1026 posts
I had a very similar experience – we started supplementing at 4 months after his well visit and I saw him drop in weight % yet again. I decided enough was enough and we went to Target after his visit to pick up formula. I remember being in tears on the way home because I felt like such a failure. I officially stopped nursing and pumping at 6.5 months and while I wish we could have lasted a little longer without needed to supplement, I am finally satisfied with how things ended up.
GOLD / papaya / 10206 posts
We’re just coming up on 13 months and she’s weaning herself. She doesn’t want to nurse, and when I offer she only nurses for a few minutes. I’m sad/happy about it! lol!
coconut / 8861 posts
We’re at a little over 7 months right now. I’m thinking that it’s time to stop nursing because it’s become all consuming in a bad way. Everything in my life right now is pumping, nursing, making sure that he’s fed. I made my 6 months goal, so it might be time to say goodbye to the nursing in order to do things for myself without guilt.
honeydew / 7968 posts
We supplemented from the beginning and I had absolutely no guilt. I was happy to breastfeed at all, now my kids are in the 90s and 80s in height and weight, which my doc says is amazing for twins.
pomelo / 5628 posts
We need more stories like this! My son was born extremely prematurely and has severe reflux. He was not eating enough to get out of the NICU and we were considering a g-tube. As a last ditch effort, we tried formula – a type already thickened for reflux and his eating took off. This was at about 4 months, but just after his due date.
My frustrating has been that I have a totally adequate supply and a ridiculous freezer stash, but I given to him (on it’s own) is not the best thing for him. I do still give him about 1/3 breast milk.
I still miss the breastfeeding relationship that we don’t have and I feel guilty like I didn’t try hard enough to make it work even though I know what he eats now is totally working for him.
blogger / apricot / 424 posts
I have a post on this coming up myself but I must say that the emotional aspect of weaning for me was difficult as well. Even though my daughter weaned herself, I still kept trying for some time and it made me very sad to feel like I had lost that connection that I had while I nursed her.
I am at peace with my decision but still wonder what it would be like to have continued nursing later then four months.
olive / 56 posts
thank you so much for this post – i know this comment is about 6 months late, but we’re going through all this now and I really, really needed to read this. It’s so easy to feel consumed by the “need” to breastfeed but making sure baby is well fed. We’re now struggling with a dip in supply, a still hungry baby and supplementing and the worry that this will be the beginning of the end
*sigh*
blogger / pomegranate / 3491 posts
@legallyheidi: hang in there. It will get better no matter what you decide to do in the long run!