My sister and I always joked about combining our families because we are so close. Well, turns out that it may really become a reality! When we moved back to Los Angeles from NYC, we crashed with my sister and it was totally fine. However, this was before any kids were in the house and it was pretty easy to live with other adults. Now that we are considering having our kids and our husbands under one roof, it really raised a lot of questions of whether this would be a good idea. Living with grandparents is pretty common, but what about a whole other family with their young kids? I am a master of making a list of pros and cons. It really helps me evaluate the issue as thoroughly as possible.
PROS of living with another family:
- entertainment for your kids (no need for play dates!)
- unlimited date nights when the kid are asleep!
- a nicer home (combining our incomes)
- the feeling of a big, full house (if you like that sort of thing)
- borrowing clothes from your older sister (lucky for me!)
- kids learning similar values they would be learning in a daycare (how to share, how to wait for others, etc.)
- becoming close to other adults
- saving money
- being able to have help at your feet when you’re sick or physically unable
- combining toys
- sharing nanny costs
CONS of living with another family:
- less alone time
- sometimes chaotic atmosphere
- having to parent another child besides your own
- more cooking
- bigger messes to clean up
- less private moments with your immediate family
- possible “roommate” type of conflicts
- possible times of our kids not getting along
- not being able to have people over without asking the other family if it’s ok
It seemed obvious to me that right now, it did seem like a good idea for us to live together. Convincing sisters to live together, even with our families, was not that big of a deal. But convincing our husbands was a whole other thing. Of course they all get along just fine, but I’m sure most people prefer having their own private living space. Everyone wants to chill out in their underwear whenever they want and not be judged if they just want to be alone. But for now, with our little ones only about 7 months apart, it seems like a good idea.
We have been searching for the right type of home. Here are some really great things to think about when it comes to living with 2 families:
- Consider having one family on each floor to make it seem more separate
- Have a meeting to formally discuss how finances, house duties would work and the expectations of living together
- Pick one day of the week when it will be “immediate family day” so that you will be able to just spend time with your own family
- Really ask how the husbands (or the non-blood family member) truly feel about each step of the way to make sure they’re on the same page
- Discuss how and when the family will move out in the future
- Make a note of how each person chooses to relax/wind down
In the end, we are hoping to find a home that will at least have a lower bedroom (and bathroom) for me and Mr. Pencil. The kids and my sister’s family will all live upstairs. We really wanted a place where the living space area, kitchen and backyard was the main attraction. We didn’t really care too much about bedrooms because according to other people who have families, we would probably spend most of our time in the living space.
. . . . .
Has anyone else had any experiences living with other families, besides the grandparents? What are some tips you can share?
coconut / 8854 posts
Wow this is so interesting! I’ve never heard of anyone doing this, besides when obviously in a pinch of some sort! I look forward to hearing more about the living situation!!
squash / 13208 posts
How will the purchase go? Will one family buy it and the other pay rent?
That would be my biggest fear is if it doesn’t work out and you all 4 signed the papers to buy the house…. then what???
guest
This is super common in Chicago where families often share a two flat. everyone has their own space and share a yard.
cantaloupe / 6730 posts
Wow, this could be very interesting. It’s funny, but I think in this case I would care about the bedrooms. Normally, I don’t think they are important, but in a situation like this where there would be times that I need to get away, I’d want to have a retreat to go to!
blogger / apricot / 335 posts
@MrsBrewer: I suppose in a way we’re sort of in a pinch, where one of us may be out of a job. But other than that, it really does help kill many birds with one stone!
@Mamaof2: Oh, I totally agree! This was a big thing. My older sister and bro-in-law are the ones buying the house and they got one they could totally afford on their own, with or without us. We sat down and discussed this many times, how much rent we would pay and that we could walk away whenever we wanted. The house is very comfortable for one family but also OK for 2 families.
@Leigh: That was our dream! But really hard to find here in California!
@Grace: I agree, everyone is so different! In this case, it was the guys (the non-blood family members) that needed their own space and since the house is very big, there’s definitely places to get away. For them, as long as they could shut the door and have some privacy, it was enough. But to each their own for sure!
squash / 13208 posts
@Mrs. Pencil: that sounds nice then – you can both save some money in the long run, the cousins get to spend lots of time together and if it doesn’t work out aren’t stuck there!
Keep us posted!!
wonderful kiwi / 23653 posts
This is so interesting! My BIL and my nephew live with my parents but it’s mostly b/c he’s a single dad so my in-laws helped raised my nephew.
I cannot imagine living with HIS siblings, but I also can’t imagine living with my sister b/c she’s so much younger.
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
Soooo excited for you guys to hopefully move closer to us!!! I love that you and your sister are so close and always there for each other – your big, fun family is just awesome!
hostess / cantaloupe / 6486 posts
This sounds super fun! I think my husband would hate it (also, I don’t even have a sister lol) but it hunk it would be a cool experince. I can’t wait to hear more!
grapefruit / 4584 posts
This is interesting! I could see living with a close sibling in a home like I currently do, which is technically a (very old and large) single family row home fully divided into two complete apartments (each home has 2-3 floors of the house with a kitchen, living room, bedrooms, etc.)…but then opening up the entry level (where we currently have locked double doors between us and the neighbors) so that people could flow freely between the two homes.
I’m not sure it’d be right for me, but I’m intrigued by the concept and will be curious to see what you decide. Sounds like it could be really fun!
pear / 1672 posts
I think this is a great idea. I know two single mothers who have done this, but not people with partners. Given the rising cost of housing and childcare, I think co-living is a great options for families.
guest
Although she is single and childless, my sister has lived with my husband, my 14-month-old, and me for the past year. It’s mostly been great; we enjoy free babysitting, having weekly nights off from making dinner, and the rent she pays us. She enjoys cheap rent, a safer neighborhood, and having a close relationship with her niece. She lives upstairs, we live downstairs, we have our own bathrooms and TVs, and I only sometimes feel like I’m cleaning up after her!