Today I saw the sweetest sight I’ve seen in a long while. No, it wasn’t a positive pregnancy test!  It was a ‘For Sale’ sign in my front yard.  Our house is finally on the market, and we are on the path to downsizing!

We entered the housing market during the crash. Because of our budget, buying a foreclosure made the most sense.  We were amazed at the diversity of homes in the foreclosure market and were wowed at how much house could be had in our very modest budget (it doesn’t hurt that we live in a rural area where homes tend toward the large in general).  Although we didn’t put size at the top of our list, we did want quite a few bedrooms and anticipated “growing into” our house.  We bought our house when I was pregnant, and at the time didn’t know what type of space a baby would require.  Before we bought our home we lived in a very small student rental, and had no experience as homeowners.  Now that we interact more frequently with other parents, we are familiar with creative home configurations.  So if we are able to expand our family, we now have a more realistic idea of how much space we actually need.  We also have more realistic ideas about what it means to be a homeowner, and the amount of energy we are willing to put into a home.

About a year after buying our home, I started to desire a downsize.  I think the phrase “downsizing” is typically associated with people approaching retirement.  But judging from what I’ve seen in the news, a lot of young adults are taking the same approach to the homebuying process.

I know for a lot of people, consciously downsizing is a luxury in itself.   So for those of you who own or rent a small house, consider this post an ode to your smaller home.  And for those of who who are thinking of buying or renting a larger home, perhaps this will be of some value to you.

Here are some of the reasons we’re excited to look for a smaller home!

ADVERTISEMENT

What is happening to our money?
Every time we get ahead financially, we immediately sink that money into our house.  This in spite knowing from personal experience and scientific studies that the money we invest into our home is less likely to make us happy than any other money we spend.

Our home is livable now, but for it to be more functional, it could use some updates. On the other hand, there’s preschool and vacations to save for, student debt to pay off, and college savings to fund. There are charitable causes to which we would love to contribute. These things are more important to us than making improvements on our home, but they are easy to put on the backburner when the next house-related disaster strikes. Although I understand the value of investing in property at a young age, I’m not sure if home ownership is always compatible with the chaotic reality of parenting a toddler. Even those of us who have enough money to make all the house updates have to make a judgement call regarding how our money might be better invested.

Major time suck.  The bigger and more complex the home, the more it takes to maintain. For example: we have a pool, and keeping it up is the equivalent of maintaining a second yard.  It requires hours of my husband’s very limited time every week. It is fun on the weekends, but it would be just as fun–and cheaper– to head over to the community pool.

Constant Conflict.   Home ownership causes a lot of marital and internal turmoil. This feels particularly acute on the weekends, when we have to choose between spending our time doing fun outings, or investing time into the house.  Even when we are at home on the weekends, we usually spend that time being productive instead of resting or playing. On weekdays we tend to divide and conquer– my husband takes the yard and I take the garden and the interior of the house.  This means that when we set aside time to work on the house, we aren’t spending that time together. When we rented, we used to clean together, but now we always spend that productive time alone. Also one person’s work is always being interrupted by the needs of a toddler! It isn’t fair to us or to our son to spend weekends lavishing attention on a home when we could be turning that attention to each other.

Odds are high that this is more of a “person problem” than a “house problem.”  We just don’t have the work ethic or organizational skills necessary to manage our family life, careers, and home ownership.  But rather than try to fix our personalities, we’ll just eliminate the house part of the equation instead!

More Consistent With Our Values.  Over the last few years, we have started paying attention to the waste we create and the energy we use. It takes a lot of energy to cool and heat our home (part of this is because we desperately need a more energy-efficient heating and cooling system, but size and layout play the biggest role). We also have to buy and accumulate a lot more stuff to maintain all the diverse areas of our home. To give you an example, yard-maintenance related clutter (multiple mowers, weed-eaters, edgers, chain saw, etc.) is a real headache for us. We have considered adding a shed to give us extra storage.  But we cringe at the idea of adding yet another structure that requires maintenance (a shed), simply for the support of another area that already requires care (a yard). Accumulating more things to maintain what you currently have feels like a never-ending trap. And with every new project comes a ton of building material waste. We recently had new flooring installed in two areas of our home, and I was discouraged by the amount of un-useable scrap we had to take to the landfill. Finally, having a large home and yard makes us more reliant on synthetic chemicals than I would like. I’d like to discontinue pest control and stop using weed-killer, but we don’t have the time to diligently do our own pest control or weed our yard, so we frequently default to chemical solutions. Plus we always have pool chemicals laying around.

Useless Spaces.  Our home features a few spaces that we don’t use at all: an entryway, a dining room that we’ve halfway converted into an office, and guest bedrooms.  It doesn’t make sense for us to heat and cool these rooms that we never use.  One thing I’d love to create in a future room is areas that can do double-duty, like a playroom or den that can be converted into a guest bedroom when we need one.

Never Feel at Home. For me, our house has never felt like home. Rather, it feels like a project that needs constant maintenance. I frequently feel ill at ease at home because I only see what needs to be done, rather than what we’ve accomplished here.

Filling space.  It is easy to accumulate stuff you really don’t need. For every beloved piece of furniture, or useful gadget, we have at least one ugly piece that we keep around simply to fill space, or one gadget we haven’t used  in years. We are messy, and having too much space encourages us to make more piles, accumulate more things, and push the clutter aside instead of tackling it as it comes into our home.

All this having been said, I’m not totally convinced that home ownership itself is a bad idea.  For now, our plan is to rent a home until we find one that ticks all of our boxes.  Since we have a lot of boxes, I don’ t anticipate buying a home any time soon!

Next time around, I think we will approach the house market differently, instead focusing on homes that are easy to maintain, and flexible for our needs.  Some of the things I’d like to see in our next place (whether rented or bought):

A shadier, more natural yard with less grass and more native groundcover, to reduce the amount of yard work that is necessary.

An older, more well-insulated home, preferably brick.

A home in the shade is also cheaper to cool.

A house with more separate spaces— not open-concept– is easier to keep clean.  It is also easier to heat and cool.

A den that we can use as a playroom, family room, and guest bedroom.

Bedrooms large enough for children to share.

A home closer to the city center to reduce driving and encourage walking.

Large windows in living areas so that we can reduce our reliance on electric lighting during the daytime.

A ranch-style home or split-level means you only have to heat one floor. Right now we have a master-on-main, and it is a pain to have to heat both floors of our home in the winter.

Room to add-on so that we don’t have to give up our dream home just to get a few more square feet, should our downsizing plan go awry.

What are you doing to make your home more energy-efficient and to make home ownership less stressful?