Today I saw the sweetest sight I’ve seen in a long while. No, it wasn’t a positive pregnancy test! It was a ‘For Sale’ sign in my front yard. Our house is finally on the market, and we are on the path to downsizing!
We entered the housing market during the crash. Because of our budget, buying a foreclosure made the most sense. We were amazed at the diversity of homes in the foreclosure market and were wowed at how much house could be had in our very modest budget (it doesn’t hurt that we live in a rural area where homes tend toward the large in general). Although we didn’t put size at the top of our list, we did want quite a few bedrooms and anticipated “growing into” our house. We bought our house when I was pregnant, and at the time didn’t know what type of space a baby would require. Before we bought our home we lived in a very small student rental, and had no experience as homeowners. Now that we interact more frequently with other parents, we are familiar with creative home configurations. So if we are able to expand our family, we now have a more realistic idea of how much space we actually need. We also have more realistic ideas about what it means to be a homeowner, and the amount of energy we are willing to put into a home.
About a year after buying our home, I started to desire a downsize. I think the phrase “downsizing” is typically associated with people approaching retirement. But judging from what I’ve seen in the news, a lot of young adults are taking the same approach to the homebuying process.
I know for a lot of people, consciously downsizing is a luxury in itself. So for those of you who own or rent a small house, consider this post an ode to your smaller home. And for those of who who are thinking of buying or renting a larger home, perhaps this will be of some value to you.
Here are some of the reasons we’re excited to look for a smaller home!
What is happening to our money? Every time we get ahead financially, we immediately sink that money into our house. This in spite knowing from personal experience and scientific studies that the money we invest into our home is less likely to make us happy than any other money we spend.
Our home is livable now, but for it to be more functional, it could use some updates. On the other hand, there’s preschool and vacations to save for, student debt to pay off, and college savings to fund. There are charitable causes to which we would love to contribute. These things are more important to us than making improvements on our home, but they are easy to put on the backburner when the next house-related disaster strikes. Although I understand the value of investing in property at a young age, I’m not sure if home ownership is always compatible with the chaotic reality of parenting a toddler. Even those of us who have enough money to make all the house updates have to make a judgement call regarding how our money might be better invested.
Major time suck. The bigger and more complex the home, the more it takes to maintain. For example: we have a pool, and keeping it up is the equivalent of maintaining a second yard. It requires hours of my husband’s very limited time every week. It is fun on the weekends, but it would be just as fun–and cheaper– to head over to the community pool.
Constant Conflict. Home ownership causes a lot of marital and internal turmoil. This feels particularly acute on the weekends, when we have to choose between spending our time doing fun outings, or investing time into the house. Even when we are at home on the weekends, we usually spend that time being productive instead of resting or playing. On weekdays we tend to divide and conquer– my husband takes the yard and I take the garden and the interior of the house. This means that when we set aside time to work on the house, we aren’t spending that time together. When we rented, we used to clean together, but now we always spend that productive time alone. Also one person’s work is always being interrupted by the needs of a toddler! It isn’t fair to us or to our son to spend weekends lavishing attention on a home when we could be turning that attention to each other.
Odds are high that this is more of a “person problem” than a “house problem.” We just don’t have the work ethic or organizational skills necessary to manage our family life, careers, and home ownership. But rather than try to fix our personalities, we’ll just eliminate the house part of the equation instead!
More Consistent With Our Values. Over the last few years, we have started paying attention to the waste we create and the energy we use. It takes a lot of energy to cool and heat our home (part of this is because we desperately need a more energy-efficient heating and cooling system, but size and layout play the biggest role). We also have to buy and accumulate a lot more stuff to maintain all the diverse areas of our home. To give you an example, yard-maintenance related clutter (multiple mowers, weed-eaters, edgers, chain saw, etc.) is a real headache for us. We have considered adding a shed to give us extra storage. But we cringe at the idea of adding yet another structure that requires maintenance (a shed), simply for the support of another area that already requires care (a yard). Accumulating more things to maintain what you currently have feels like a never-ending trap. And with every new project comes a ton of building material waste. We recently had new flooring installed in two areas of our home, and I was discouraged by the amount of un-useable scrap we had to take to the landfill. Finally, having a large home and yard makes us more reliant on synthetic chemicals than I would like. I’d like to discontinue pest control and stop using weed-killer, but we don’t have the time to diligently do our own pest control or weed our yard, so we frequently default to chemical solutions. Plus we always have pool chemicals laying around.
Useless Spaces. Our home features a few spaces that we don’t use at all: an entryway, a dining room that we’ve halfway converted into an office, and guest bedrooms. It doesn’t make sense for us to heat and cool these rooms that we never use. One thing I’d love to create in a future room is areas that can do double-duty, like a playroom or den that can be converted into a guest bedroom when we need one.
Never Feel at Home. For me, our house has never felt like home. Rather, it feels like a project that needs constant maintenance. I frequently feel ill at ease at home because I only see what needs to be done, rather than what we’ve accomplished here.
Filling space. It is easy to accumulate stuff you really don’t need. For every beloved piece of furniture, or useful gadget, we have at least one ugly piece that we keep around simply to fill space, or one gadget we haven’t used in years. We are messy, and having too much space encourages us to make more piles, accumulate more things, and push the clutter aside instead of tackling it as it comes into our home.
All this having been said, I’m not totally convinced that home ownership itself is a bad idea. For now, our plan is to rent a home until we find one that ticks all of our boxes. Since we have a lot of boxes, I don’ t anticipate buying a home any time soon!
Next time around, I think we will approach the house market differently, instead focusing on homes that are easy to maintain, and flexible for our needs. Some of the things I’d like to see in our next place (whether rented or bought):
A shadier, more natural yard with less grass and more native groundcover, to reduce the amount of yard work that is necessary.
An older, more well-insulated home, preferably brick.
A home in the shade is also cheaper to cool.
A house with more separate spaces— not open-concept– is easier to keep clean. It is also easier to heat and cool.
A den that we can use as a playroom, family room, and guest bedroom.
Bedrooms large enough for children to share.
A home closer to the city center to reduce driving and encourage walking.
Large windows in living areas so that we can reduce our reliance on electric lighting during the daytime.
A ranch-style home or split-level means you only have to heat one floor. Right now we have a master-on-main, and it is a pain to have to heat both floors of our home in the winter.
Room to add-on so that we don’t have to give up our dream home just to get a few more square feet, should our downsizing plan go awry.
What are you doing to make your home more energy-efficient and to make home ownership less stressful?
blogger / pomegranate / 3491 posts
This is so interesting to read. We are still renters, and I have been coveting space for a long time. This definitely brings up some interesting points to keep in mind – thanks for sharing your thought process with us
wonderful clementine / 24134 posts
Great post – we are also in the throws of dealing with home ownership while trying to be working parents and its tough!
One thought though (from the other side of the fence) on the yard/shadiness.
We bought our house because of the mature trees (shade, beauty, yea) and the mix of a lawn (great for kids) and natural beds (low maintenance). Now that we have lived here for almost 4 years though, the yard really bothers us.
First, its still a lot of maintenance (mower, edger, chainsaw for the trees etc). Whether you have 5 trees or 20 trees you need that stuff. A small yard or a large yard still needs to be mowed.
Second, the lovely trees that shade our house, they make a huge mess 80% of the year. We are constantly bringing in dirt and leaves because the entrance ways to our house are messy from the trees. When it rains, we deal with a lot of mold on the house because it never dries up (and we live in sunny Florida!). We also have a hard time with growing grass because of the shade of the trees. Also, we often get “cabin fever” due to the lack of natural light coming in the house (this is more a window issue but the trees contribute).
Third, a lot of the natural beds have caused us issues due to bugs (mosquitos, beetles, etc) and other natural plants like poison ivy growing in them. Plus they just aren’t pretty and I feel like our yard is constantly a “mess”.
hostess / wonderful persimmon / 25556 posts
Very interesting! Do you think you will lose money on your house since you have only lived there for a year or has your market bounced back quickly? I always worry about that with quick moves. I think I just broke even when I bought my first house and sold it 2 years later. That was tough to handle but we moved into a house that was a good price and pay more on so we could obtain our goal of paying it off early.
We are both conscious about how we spend our money. We try to conserve energy as much as possible. We live in the south, so it is HOT during the summer. We bought black out curtains for the windows. In the summer, we keep the blinds and curtains drawn to prevent the heat from penetrating the house too much. We notice a huge difference if we leave our curtains open than when we don’t. So, if you get big windows, I suggest getting nice, thick curtains for those really hot days (with tie backs for when it’s not a gazillion degrees out)!
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
we’ve never been homeowners but i’ve lived in a ton of different types of homes with my family growing up, and i vastly prefer smaller, one level homes. when we had too many separate spaces, the family interacted less and less as we got older. when we lived in a small space, we were together all the time because there was nowhere else to go.
kiwi / 511 posts
These are some interesting points but I would like to give you some thought about some of the items you want to focus on for your next home.
“A shadier, more natural yard with less grass and more native groundcover, to reduce the amount of yard work that is necessary.” Not all ground cover is equal some of it is no fun to play on so if this is one of your criteria, walk on that ground cover barefoot to see if you really like it. Because “groundcover” can and will take over if you don’t maintain it and it can be a bigger PITA than grass.
“An older, more well-insulated home” this made me laugh, in NE there are plenty of old and older homes, very few are more well insulated. For reference mine was build in the mid 70s and added on in the mid 80s, the 80s portion has more insulation in the walls than the original structure.
“A ranch-style home or split-level” a potential pitfall of this style house to consider is where the furnace and the length of the house. Again for reference ours is a raised ranch but it is really really long. The furnace is not in the center of the footprint so there are long heating duct runs. That means the end of the run is in the family room and office and they are always cooler in the winter than the rest of the house.
To get back to your questions things we have done to make our house a bit more energy efficient:
(1) Curtains/Drapes whatever you want to call them make them insulated curtains, preferably with a white backing so in the summer when you close curtains the white reflects heat back out of the house. I did this DIY because I really loved my curtains I was able to score a great deal on white fleece fabric (which doesn’t fray so no sewing needed) and then I used iron on stitch witchery to apply the fleece to the panels. This helped the family room and office feel slightly warmer. I also added honeycomb white blinds. I did this in the winter so I haven’t see the effects for the summer, if it ever arrives I hope to see how it works since most of our windows are south facing. (1a) I really would be interested in setting up some home automation to close all the curtains at a specific time and open them. I detest the idea of the all intrusive Google, so I refuse to get Nest. I am hoping that next year will free up some time so my DH can program something for the house.
(2) the foam inserts in the outlets, weather stripping our doors, and making sure the windows were actually caulked. We had missed a few windows when the new ones were installed.
Something I am considering but haven’t fully worked out is to plant a wind break on the property. With the wind patterns on our property (and it is pretty windy this year) I think the best location is on the eastern facing and northern facing sides. They would likely be quick growing tall arborvitaes, they would be a help but not a 100% full proof thing since they wouldn’t grow to the height of the house, and I really don’t like and don’t want to add more pine or hemlocks to the property.
honeydew / 7444 posts
We actually went the opposite direction and are moving into a bigger home (1200 to 1700 sq ft), but the move will help eliminate a lot of headaches in our old house.
Our old 1960s house sits on a huge lot with mature trees and like one of the above commenters makes a huge mess and ruins the lawns (crab apples, pine cones, blossoms, etc.). It also takes 1.5 hours to mow/weed. I also had to laugh at the old houses having better insulation because that is so not the case! I know the above commenter already mentioned it, but there are lots of issues with split-levels because there is usually uneven temperature distribution throughout the house, with certain areas being crazy drafty. I only know this because of friends who have these homes, and when we looked into split-level homes as well.
Though our new home costs more, i’ll be happier knowing it’s going to the mortgage than towards fixing/improving things (i agree it’s depressing). I also will look forward to our small yard, and better insulated home! Good luck with finding you next home.
blogger / persimmon / 1220 posts
Great list! Home ownership is definitely stressful!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
Exciting about the move!! You’ll have to write another post about the kind of house you guys finally end up with and how closely it fits your criteria!
This is the first I’ve read of someone not wanting an open concept home! I find it pretty easy to clean, so just wondering where you got the idea that it’s more difficult to clean from? I like that when I’m cooking, I can see the kids playing in the living room, and it’s easier to entertain guests when everyone is in one open space. It feels more homey and convenient to me.
Sounds like most of your reasons have to do with energy efficiency! We are renting solar panels to combat our energy use, and it’s going to save us money in the long run.
Older homes tend to have more maintenance problems, so that’s something to keep in mind. They are often not as well insulated, I would avoid wood sidings at all costs!!, and they tend to have more piping problems.
I like one level homes too. It’s definitely something to consider if this will be your forever home because it is so ideal for older folks!
persimmon / 1171 posts
These are the reasons I used to convince DH for a smaller house. No one believes us that our 1200sqft home is our forever home because “we’ll eventually need more space” or whatever…um, no. We have the basics and I absolutely love that the house is small enough to keep clean and discourages me from buying more stuff I don’t need. Good luck house hunting!
GOLD / wonderful coconut / 33402 posts
We have so many trees in our yard and DH hates that we can’t get sod to grow in the back. But it helps SO much with keeping our house cool!!
kiwi / 511 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: I am not a fan of the open concept because I cannot hide the clutter
Our house is partially open but I can easily close the door to the office, and family room if needed.
The kitchen is open to a dining area and a living room (or sitting room whatever you want to call it. It has a radio, chairs, and a love seat but no other media and the kids don’t play there. My Mom likes to read in that room because it is away from the TV.
Oh and one other potential for single floor living….noise. My Grandmother had a ranch and I hated it because if you were in the bedroom you could still hear stuff going on in the kitchen or living room (both depending on who was up). It drove me bonkers, to the point that I refused for the longest time to look at any single level houses. In my house as I mentioned above it is really really long so I don’t have that issue with noise transfer so people can sleep if they want to sleep while someone is up doing things. But I have the long heating run problem. So as with all things in life there are trade offs, it is simply a matter of figuring out what is right for your individual situation.
GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts
@mediagirl: We’ve been in our house a little over two years now. The market here is very slow…houses in our range (size/price) take a minimum of six months to sell (according to my realtor’s numbers)! So we felt like we just needed to put it out there so we can start the waiting game. I’m fully expecting to be in this house next year! If we can get out of it what we paid, I’ll be happy. Our house was built in 1987 and it has the cathedral livingroom with the two-story windows. As an SAHM it is my favorite feature of the house because it is so nice not to have to use lights during the day. But in all the bedrooms, which also have floor-to-ceiling windows, we have blackout curtains! If I was WOHM I’d definitely get drapes for our living room, but since we spend so much time in there, I appreciate the brightness and I feel like the energy spendings even out.
@Mrs.Maven: @Freckles: Maybe we just got lucky! The last two places we lived were built in the late fifties/early sixties and the walls were so hard that we couldn’t even get nails in them! The last place we lived we heated with propane heaters even! But that is pretty old. I think once you get into the late sixties/seventies/eighties it can be pretty dicey. Our house was built in 87 and it feels flimsy to me….vinyl siding, etc. I guess new build is probably the best in terms of energy-efficiency, but I do love the feel of older homes, plus I like the idea of “reusing” a house! I agree about ranch homes being hard to heat evenly. Right now we have two furnaces (upstairs and downstairs), and it seems like one or the other is on the fritz so we never get the benefits of both. Also our upstairs hallway (where our thermostat is) is open to the bottom level of the house so our thermostats are always getting confused and overheating or underheating based on the temperature of the other floor (if that makes sense). I guess there’s no winning that battle….!
GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts
@Mrs. High Heels: I feel like when I’m in an open concept home I am always surrounded by my own clutter! We don’t have an open concept house now, but it is semi open concept? It has a wide entry from kitchen to living room with no door. I can’t always see LO but can usually hear him and only have to lean over from the counter to see into the room. But to me it feels like messes always creep from one room to another. Toy mess in living room, office mess in kitchen, etc. We have a large eat-in kitchen and I kinda hate it because after I’m done preparing food I have to then serve the meal in all the mess I’ve just made! I’d like to be able to just shut the door to the kitchen and eat in a place that is not so messy, lol. But our dining room has hardwood floors whereas our kitchen has tile, so it is more practical to have toddlers throwing food on a tile floor vs. wood. Also I hate when you can see the TV from the place where you eat! I can’t help but watch! Maybe it would be best just to eliminate the TV in that case…! lol!
GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts
@Mrs.Maven: OMG. My ILs have a ranch and the main bathroom is right off the kitchen. So stressful! Everyone is in there getting dinner ready…and I need to pee…..gah! And at night I’m afraid I’m going to wake everyone if I need to pee and flush the toilet. So yeah, the older style where the bedrooms are in a hallway are better in that regard than the ones where the bedrooms orbit the center of the house.
GOLD / nectarine / 2884 posts
@Mrs.Maven: here’s a hilarious excoriation of the open concept kitchen. It is a little too much, but at the same time I totally get it!
http://www.slate.com/articles/life/culturebox/2013/08/against_open_concept_kitchens_don_t_listen_to_hgtv_and_keep_your_walls_and.html
grapefruit / 4187 posts
I totally agree with all of your points! As we prepare to move out of the city and are looking at houses, i prefer a small to mid sized less open concept house. I also really dislike “catwalks” where the upstairs is open to the downstairs. It gives the bedrooms less privacy and is so scary as a parent thinking of a mischievous toddler exploring and possibly falling through. I’ve also thought about the heating/cooling bills and maintenance. While we could afford a larger home I dont want to spend sll of our disposable income maintaining it. And I love to diy but I agree about not wanting to spend the entire weekend working on the house.
I live in800 sq ft right now with dh and lo and love it! Of course we do need a little more space, but not much really. I just need a 3rd bedroom, 2nd full bath, finished basement and decent sized yard.
blogger / pear / 1563 posts
This is really interesting! We have recently thought about getting a house we can “grow into” but have decided to stay in our small home for at least another year or two, for a lot of the reasons you listed above! I can’t imagine having to clean a house much larger than ours.
blogger / nectarine / 2600 posts
I could never down size and I fully admit it as I dream of a larger home daily but it is interesting to see the other perspectives
clementine / 990 posts
I love your honesty!
I live in Western Canada where it seems like everyone buys the absolute biggest house they can afford. It makes me insane in so many ways. There’s actually a guy building an ENORMOUS house right off the hwy. It has SEVEN drive through garage stalls. It looks like a hotel!
Anyway, we just moved to a bigger, new home so I could be closer to work. So the new house is more energy efficient than our old house. We had honeycomb blinds installed – “energy efficient” in the north and south facing windows, and blackout on the bedroom windows. We intend on planting tall, native trees along the southern perimeter of our yard to help shade the house and yard, and we are trying to do as little grass as possible, and keep it all native so that we don’t have to do too much extra water and maintenance.
We got a bigger house, which, truly, is more than I can keep up while parenting a toddler and working 40 hours a week, so we are having someone come in to clean every week. Like you, we spend a whole day on the weekend cleaning, etc. it sucks. But, we enjoy having less house maintenance. We could afford to have everything finished (including the basement) in this house, and it’s really nice to have everything done, and to have everything we need. We also need to get a bit more organized to make this home really work for us, but I think it’s a lot closer than our old house.
blogger / nectarine / 2687 posts
i can’t wait to see what you end up with! we are currently in a 1500 sq foot home and while the square footage isn’t too bad, the layout is kind of stupid, so i’d love to move into a slightly bigger space that is better laid out!
blogger / persimmon / 1398 posts
Oh, I’m so excited to follow this journey of yours!! We’ve tried to sell for the same reasons… so I’m sending lots of positive thoughts your way! (And the “separate space” thing is at the top of my list for the next go around!)
blogger / clementine / 750 posts
My hat is off to you! Good luck!