Since giving birth to Fiona, and even when I was pregnant with her and out and about with Drake & Juliet, the big question I always heard was, “So you’re done now, right?” I get this a lot even from my own family, where the question comes off more as a statement rather than question. Truthfully I don’t get upset by this comment, as many people I know do, and the easiest answer seems to be simply saying yes, watching the relief wash over their face confirming their feelings. But the reality is what I say out loud to others and what I feel inside don’t always match up.
Growing up as an only child had a very deep effect on how I dreamed about the family I would hopefully one day have myself. When I met Mr. Chocolate in college it was an already well known that I wanted a big family with lots of kids, I used to say I hoped for nine. Growing up I felt so lonely all the time, the house was so quiet and I was left to my own devices for hours on end for years. As a little girl all I ever wanted was a sibling; someone to talk to, play with, and even commiserate with when I felt my parents were being unreasonable or unfair. It seemed like everyone in the world but me had a sibling. I dreamed of a loud rowdy home, similar to the one depicted in Home Alone (minus of course the forgetting the kid bit) filled with children’s laughter and screams of delight, artwork covering the refrigerator, and organized chaos in all areas of the house.
When Mr. Chocolate and I got married he was well aware of my hopes for family and like how it often is in our relationship, he found a way to temper my grandiose ideas with practicality and rationality as he always does. Mr. Chocolate always wanted to be a father after all; he just didn’t want to be a father to nine as it turns out.
When I was pregnant with Drake, I was so excited at the possibility of finally becoming a mother and creating the family I had hoped to have through all my girlhood dreams. The reality of Drake though after birth was quite a shock. Between the sleep deprivation, and weight loss/breastfeeding issues, Drake really traumatized me; for a short time I considered throwing all my ideas of a large family out the door and keeping him as an only child for my sanity. Mr. Chocolate, however, always wanted two kids. He would have been happy with just two, but he knew that I would one day look back and regret not having more.
After some time he eventually convinced me to try again for another and three years and two weeks after Drake’s birth, Juliet arrived. Before Juliet’s arrival I had a lot of apprehensions about the change from being a mom to one to a mom of two, partially because of the trauma of Drake’s first year, and partially because I was worried how a sibling would affect him, even though I had wished for this moment for so much of my own life. And then Juliet was born and we quickly adapted to a family of four. Juliet, for her part, was always much easier child than Drake had ever been, and once we had her, I knew I wanted more. The worries I had for Drake vanished when I saw how much he adored having a little sister, and Juliet would never know life without at least one sibling anyway. Mr Chocolate knowing about my childhood as well as the fact that I had lost a few cousins (whose siblings then became only children) agreed to have one more. I wondered how I ever could have imagined having nine kids; the thought of nine labors is enough to scare me out of it alone.
During my pregnancy with Fiona, I was very conscious that this was my last pregnancy, my last delivery, my last baby. From the moment Fiona was placed in my arms, I almost felt like I could feel time slipping away from me with every second, making her one more moment older and one step closer to the end of an era in my life. Fiona is only a month old now and that in itself seems so shocking… shocking that I survived a month of newborn sleep deprivation and that one month has flown by so fast. But now that we are here, I find myself honestly wondering am I really “done?”
Our lives for the last few years have been planned on the idea of three. Our house has enough bedrooms for each child, our car has enough space to accommodate them all, and truthfully our finances probably are best suited for one, but we will find a way. On days when all three are driving me crazy I can’t imagine adding one more, and if you catch me at a bad moment I might even offer you to take two, possibly three. In my heart I know three is what’s best, three is what we had planned for, three is what we can manage emotionally, financially, and physically. I’m not getting younger and I already feel pulled in all directions at times by the wants and needs of them all. In my mind I know that “we are done,” but my heart oh my heart… it’s still not sure.
Looking back at my lonely childhood I see those dreams: the chaotic but lively house, the teenage kids who miraculously all get along, the graduations, the engagements and weddings, the grandkids I’ll rock in my arms. In my heart I can see it, but in my mind I also see the toil it takes to raise those little kids into self sufficient, capable, kind adults. It’s like looking at a finished product without seeing all the time, energy, and work it took, the devotion and care that sucks every ounce of energy and strength out of you to create. When Fiona was born I thought, with all this foreseen knowledge, that I would feel done. That my ovaries would close up and my heart too to the idea of another baby. And yet a week after her birth in the dead of night while the rest of the house slept and I was the lone soul pacing the bedroom with a fussy baby fighting sleep, a small voice popped up that said “I think I want another one.”
I don’t know if I will ever feel “done.” Mr Chocolate has made it clear he is done, and on many days for all the aforementioned reasons I know we should be done. Perhaps “done” is a feeling that some of us just never have. What I do have though is three beautiful children, children who squeal at delight when they wake up and see one another, children who sit side by side in the car in their car seats, children who are messy and loud and chaotic, who make my heart swell and my brain implode seemingly at the same time some days. I have the dream I longed for since my childhood, and it’s every bit as fantastic as I thought it would be…most of the time at least. I’m blessed and I know it so for now while I may not be “done,” I think I can easily say my heart is content.
All my blessings together
pomegranate / 3212 posts
I got this question, well, statement, about our being done after my second was born. Hate it.
Love the post, thanks for sharing with us.
guest
This post really spoke to me. I’m pregnant with my third and have really been pondering “being done” having children. It just seems like such a huge thing. Thank you for sharing.
wonderful olive / 19353 posts
I’m pregnant with #2, which we just found out is a girl, and I know many people will automatically assume we’re done (we’ll have 1 boy and 1 girl). While I’m still pregnant now, I’m kind of open to a 3rd, when DH and I originally agreed on 3 if we doubled up. I’ll reconsider once DD is born and see how the 1st year goes.
blogger / nectarine / 2043 posts
Gah, why do people say these things? To me this is no better than “when are you having kids?” and “when are you having the next one?” I’m a snarky jerk, I always answer something obnoxious (and if I had more than one, I’d say “nah, I’m going for a full soccer team” or something like that).
cantaloupe / 6791 posts
My second was born the same day as Fiona and I’ve heard from multiple people the same comment. I want three- it’s always how I imagined my family and I don’t feel done yet. Maybe it’s because these two were so close together (20 months) that people feel the need to comment. Also, I can see myself feeling the exact same way when I have my third (about everything being the “last” time).
guest
I have the same problem. I have a boy and a girl and people assume I am done, but I don’t feel done. I want a third, but my husband says he is done. It heartbreaking to not feel done, but “told” either by strangers or your spouse that you are done.
apricot / 370 posts
beautiful picture and congratulations on Fiona. I have 2 girls, and we’re done. I don’t mind so much when people ask if I’m having more, but I don’t like it when ppl try to ask in a telling way, “don’t you want a boy”? uhhhh no that’s not why I had children.
pomegranate / 3225 posts
What a beautiful family! Thank you for sharing. I’m struggling with this. I have two and I feel like I can’t possibly handle a third… BUT. Sigh.
blogger / kiwi / 588 posts
I totally feel you! This post totally describes how things are for me. I, too was a lonely only child and grew up wanting a sibling. So when DH and I decided to start having kids I said I wanted at least two, but four would be great! We now have two, one boy and one girl, and most people assume that we are done because of that. (DD is almost 9 months and DS is almost 2.5 years.) I’ve been saying that we’ll see if there will be third after DD turns one, at least it gives her time to be the baby a little bit longer. Something about closing the door on pregnancy and having kids doesn’t settle with me yet, I guess we’ll see what happens.
blogger / kiwi / 626 posts
Oh my goodness, this is so close to my heart. I’ve always wanted three children and we have the two right now and Mr. Cereal says he is done but I just don’t feel done. I am pushing for another sometime down the road and it makes me really sad to think about not adding the third child to our family. I’m hoping that the tides will change in a year and we can try for a third.
apple seed / 2 posts
I love how you write from the heart! I always wanted a really big family, and even before getting pregnant with my first child, I knew it wouldn’t be a reality. But I hope that as I add to my family, it will have that chaotic, happy ‘big family’ feeling.
guest
I love this! There are also the comments about gender that I hate!! I am currently pregnant with my 3rd, and having 2 amazing girls at home, I get the “oh, so decided to try for the boy” comments. Um no. We wanted a third CHILD. No matter the gender and honestly, I would be happy with a girl. I like being a “girl mom”. I am a little frightened about raising a boy, lol. We won’t find out for 2 more weeks but until then, I’m neutral
Of course we also get the “you’re gonna be done, right?” Or even “If it is a girl, will you try again” – we didn’t “try” this time! Ugh. people. 
haha, love it!).
(My first born is named Fiona as well… don’t hear it too often so it was a suprise to hear your daughter’s name
blogger / kiwi / 675 posts
beautiful post! I am so happy for you, you are inspiring me to go for a 3rd, we’ve been heavily considering it. I love your writing and congratulations on Fiona shes absolutely precious!!! Juliet has gotten so big and Drake too! (I’ve been out of blogging for a bit
)