I’m a pretty lax parent when it comes to supervision because I’m from the generation where we were all allowed to play outside completely unsupervised, and I’m trying to give my kids some of that childhood. Olive and Charlie are 7 1/2 and 9 1/2 years old and I’ve been leaving them alone in limited durations in the car (with the engine on), our house, stores, and restaurants for years here in the Philippines (something I wouldn’t be able to do in the US). But one thing I will never do is let my kids swim unsupervised.
Living on an island with a pool, you can imagine that we get more than our fair share of water time. Both Charlie and Olive have had swim lessons and continue to get them regularly as their babysitters are also swim teachers. They are both very confident in the water, but that actually makes me even more vigilant; Charlie especially is likely to take more risks because he is so confident in his swimming ability. Many parents here let their kids swim in pools without direct supervision where adults are around, but not specifically watching the kids. For this reason there are very few people I trust to watch my kids swimming because I know most won’t be as vigilant as I am!
Here are some sobering facts about drowning for you:
- Drowning kills more children 1-4 years of age than anything else except birth defects. Among children 1-14, drowning is the second leading cause of unintentional injury death (after motor vehicle crashes). (source)
- Although the months of May through August are peak time for drownings, the month of June is the most dangerous month of the year for kids losing their lives in this way (source)
- More than half of drownings among infants occur in bathtubs. (source)
- In nine out of 10 drownings, parents or caregivers say they’d been supervising the child at the time (source)
- Most childhood drownings in pools occur in the child’s home pool. About one-third of these drownings occur in pools at the homes of friends, neighbors, or relatives. (source)
- Two-thirds of kids who drown, believe it or not, are excellent swimmers. (source)
- Older children, teens and young adults typically drown in natural water settings, such as lakes and rivers. (source)
- Nearly 80% of people who die from drowning are male. (source)
- If a child is missing, check the water first. As many as 69% of young children who are found drowned or submerged in swimming pools were not expected to be in or at the pool. (source)
At a recent pool party, a three-year-old who couldn’t swim walked straight into the pool without making a single sound and sunk to the bottom. His mom was watching and immediately dove into the pool to rescue him. Had she not been watching, he could easily have drowned because with everything going on, no one else noticed him entering the pool. Drowning doesn’t involve shouting and flailing about like it’s portrayed in the movies; with kids it’s usually silent because they’ve swallowed water or have already slipped below the surface.
There are no specific guidelines as to when kids can swim unsupervised, but most seem to suggest the age of 12 as the absolute youngest age, with some even going as high as 15. I definitely plan on watching my kids closely until they’re at least 13 years old!
As summer vacations start and families head to beaches and pools, please educate yourself on water safety and drowning prevention for kids!
- Swim Lessons Won’t Keep Your Toddler From Drowning. In fact, they could put your child at higher risk. via Slate
- Prevention of Drowning via AAP
- How to Prevent Child Drowning: A Must-Read Guide for Parents via Parents
- Drowning doesn’t look like drowning via Motherly
- My Toddler Drowned And Here’s What I Want You To Know via Scary Mommy
- I Was Only a Few Feet Away When My Daughter Almost Drowned via Her View From Home
- When great swimmers drown via Today
pear / 1565 posts
Yes, all the news I see/read/hear on drowning just hits so close to home b/c it’s always kids in similar ages to my kids.
Neither of my kids know how to swim, and thankfully we don’t have a pool at our house. They go swimming a lot at my parent’s pool (a community pool) and even with puddle jumpers, we always do 1-1 in the pool no matter what.
I feel like in this day and age you just cannot be careful enough. Even at playgrounds, I’m always IN the playground with my kids vs just watching on the sidelines; so many stories of attempt abduction
squash / 13199 posts
Such an important and timely post. There have already been some drownings this month in our area and it’s so terrifying. We had an incident last summer with my 6 year old at the time and even though she was wearing a puddle jumper the home owner told us the pool was only 5 ft deep which she is used to but it was actually closer to 13ft and the depth scared her and she panicked!! At the same event another child accidentally fell in the pool and her mom was inside chatting!! Thank goodness we were out there. Honestly since then I decline pool parties because I don’t like the socializing and drinking while my kid is vulnerably near or in the water.
pomegranate / 3355 posts
Thank you for the important post. This is one of my biggest fears!!! We vacationed at a home with a pool and I was extremely vocal in literally asking every single adult there to please help watch my 2 yo bc he is fast and fearless. I tried to keep him in my sight at all times and it was exhausting BUT I’d rather be exhausted and over vigilant than the other…
pear / 1622 posts
Thank you for this post!
pomelo / 5084 posts
Ugh this makes me extremely nervous. My son’s daycare provides swimming lessons on Mondays over the summer. He just started this week. He is 3.5 and does NOT know how to swim, or about water safety. They have four of their own teachers, a swim coach, and a lifeguard at the pool (for 15 kids) but I am still freaked out. We very very nearly didnt allow him to participate but decided to go ahead in the end.
Should we pull him out of the class? What do other moms think?
guest
I so agree! My six year old’s summer program does swimming twice a week and I refuse to let him. They have a “baby pool” that’s only 2-3 feet deep, but he’s not a great swimmer and I don’t trust just a lifeguard to watch him. It’s hard to be that parent but my sister works with kids who have almost drowned and have traumatic brain injuries and it’s better to be safe than popular.
guest
I agree-pools are so scary! The idea of waiting until 12 or 13 to swim alone sounds hard and I wonder what the reasoning is? I was on a swim team at 9 years old participating in races, etc. Though I guess I was technically supervised rhwn!
pear / 1622 posts
@wrkbrk: My son started lessons at 3.5 but a parent must be there for the lesson and I am not sure at this point if I would feel comfortable not being there. I have heard of some places not wanting the parent in sight of the child so maybe it is not that rare to do what your daycare is doing. How many teachers per child in the water? I am guessing they secure the kids while the one swims with the teacher.
pomelo / 5084 posts
@autumnleaves: I’m not sure. They claim one kid goes in at a time and the others sit on the side…..
pomelo / 5084 posts
@autumnleaves: I totally agree with you. These are lessons on “swim safety” (supposedly) – not just open swim time. But I’m still not thrilled.
wonderful cherry / 21504 posts
@wrkbrk: my daughter did a gym and swim class that involved basic swim lessons- one kid in the water and the rest sat on the side. I peaked in one class and the other kids really did sit on the side and there was a teacher dedicated to just making sure the kids stayed sitting. It seemed very safe to me. Is there any way you can view a lesson?
I won’t let me almost 6 year old do certain camps where they swim because I don’t trust her swimming abilities (not good despite lots of lessons) or that teenage camp counselors and life guards can really watch all those kids that carefully. And I used to be that camp counselor!!
pomelo / 5084 posts
@Foodnerd81: Yes, we could. That might actually be a really good compromise. Thank you!