Last year we had our first run in with peer pressure and Halloween costumes. I will admit I was not ready for it. So far my sons have had no issues and they are in the second grade. They have picked their costumes, gone to school and everyone was fine. Last year was different. Last year my daughter was in preschool. She picked Hermione Granger, a character she loves and admires. We made her costume and even bought her a Croockshanks cat to carry with her. She was thrilled with her costume and was so excited to wear it on Halloween.
Then it happened. The day before Halloween they went around their preschool and everyone said what they were going to be. That night I sat with her as she cried about her costume choice. Everyone else was going to be a princess and they didn’t like Hermione. Her costume wasn’t going to be pretty and sparkly and therefore it was deemed a bad choice by her friends. I wasn’t sure how to handle it. Pressure to be like everyone else was starting in preschool?
I sat down with her and asked her why she picked Hermione in the first place. She looked at me like it was the most ridiculous question in the world. She said, “Mom, Hermione is the coolest person. She is smart and nice and can solve any problem. I want to be like Hermione.” I asked her what made her want to be a princess. She said “all the other girls are going as princesses.”
It really was heartbreaking to me. Here my daughter at age four, was able to articulate that she picked her costume because the character was smart and could solve problems, but was teased because she wasn’t a princess. I asked her what she thought Hermione would do. Would she be the character she wanted because they were awesome or would she be a princess because they were sparkly? It took her awhile but she eventually came to the conclusion that Hermione would definitely pick the costume she thought was the best and not just the prettiest or had the most sparkles. So she went to bed that night feeling better about her costume choice.
When she went to school the next day she walked in her parade with a big smile on her face and loved every minute of it. She was Hermione Granger and she was proud of it. I was proud of her but I still couldn’t believe I was already having these conversations with her about peer pressure and being true to you… at 4 years old. I have a feeling as we traverse being a young girl in today’s society I am going to have many more of these conversations.
At this time of year when we are picking our costumes and getting ready for some good family fun, I can’t help but think about the Halloween scene in the movie Mean Girls. The main character Cady starts to explain Halloween.
In the regular world, Halloween is when children dress up in costumes and beg for candy. In Girl World, Halloween is the one night a year when a girl can dress like a total slut and no other girls can say anything about it.
She goes on to say that the hardcore girls just wear lingerie and animal ears all while the dad is looking on in horror as his daughter poses in provocative stances. Cady shows up to the party in what I would consider a pretty good zombie bride costume, but everyone looked at her like she was crazy because her costume was not sexy.
I know that Mean Girls is an exaggeration. But sometimes I think it’s not as exaggerated as I wish it was. I want to raise a strong young girl who is comfortable in her skin. I want her to be able to pick her Halloween costume without being worried about not fitting in. Last year it was princess and sparkles but what happens when she is a teen and everything is super short and super tight? I want her to know she is beautiful without provocative clothing, or without the best or most sparkly outfit. I want her to feel like she can wear the costumes she wants to wear without being teased for her choices.
During the normal school year she doesn’t seem to have a problem telling people she likes her outfits even if they are a little crazy. I don’t know if it helps you picture the craziness, but Mr. Train has mentioned that she reminds him a bit of Punky Brewster. Yeah, she rocks some crazy color combinations that just make us laugh, but she does it with confidence and pride. Why is it then that Halloween made her doubt herself?
I don’t even want to get into available costumes these days and the over-sexualization of female costumes. That is a discussion for a whole different post. I just wish all the girls in her class could be excited for each other. I wish they didn’t tear each other down. I wish there wasn’t this pressure to have just the right costume. It is supposed to be a fun day to dress up and enjoy not to stress about perfection. I don’t know how to protect her from harmful words. I’m new to this territory of “girl world.” I just hope I can support her when she is upset and model kind and loving behaviors. That is the best I can do.
This year she has decided to be Jubilee from the X-men. Again she loves her character and loves her costume. I just pray when it comes time to go to school that she is ready to go out there with confidence and a smile.
guest
As a girl who insisted on being a cowBOY for Halloween when I was in elementary school, and still loves Hermione in her 30s, I completely understand! Your daughter is wise beyond her years, and her independent thinking will take her much further in life than following the herd mentality, even if it isn’t easy now. Wonderful that you are supporting her so well just as she is! Good job mama. We only have a 1.5yr old, and #2 on the way, but I pray our kiddos have this kind of confidence as well!
kiwi / 705 posts
This is completely heartbreaking to me. My daughter just turned 3 and I had no idea this might be so close! It sounds like you handled it exactly right though and your daughter makes a fantastic Hermione!
cherry / 222 posts
Thank you for this!
guest
Great job mom- I imagine this will continue to be an issue and you handled it beautifully. Can I ask how your preschooler knows hermoine or x-men? My hubby and I love both but how’d you introduce them to your kids.
That was my Halloween surprise with my 3 year old-how does he even know who Spider-Man is?
wonderful olive / 19353 posts
First off, her Hermione costume is flipping awesome!!! Secondly, I can’t believe peer pressure and bullying starts so young! 4 years old?! Man… I’m so proud of your daughter (and you for explaining it the way you did) on why she picked Hermione and reasoned it through for sticking with her choice! This is something I worry a lot about for my kids, especially my daughter. Thankfully, she’s only 7 months right now, but with evolving times. Yikes!!
hostess / wonderful persimmon / 25556 posts
I love that she went as Hermione even though the other girls didn’t think it was cool. I see this already in preschool, as well. One day I overheard a conversation between 3 girls. Two were wearing princess nightgowns (on pj day) the other was wearing skeleton pj’s. One girl in a princess nightgown said, “Aren’t you sad you aren’t wearing a princess nightgown?” And the other girl sadly said, “I like my jammies.” It was so sad to hear.
cherry / 100 posts
Brava to you for raising such a strong, confident girl. You handled the situation so well.
I have a 1 yo daughter and this post confirms my biggest fears. Like other posters, I can’t believe it starts so young.
pomelo / 5220 posts
admin / watermelon / 14210 posts
love you and love her!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
First, she rocks her Hermione costume. I love the reasons she picked to be Hermione.
I’m sad to hear stuff like this starts so soon.
I think you handled it well. You’re an amazing mom!
cherry / 141 posts
Princesses are boring anyway but I understand that kids want to belong too. My daughter chose to be a bat and she is 4. I’m really really really glad she didn’t want to be a frilly princess. Although I must say she has requested to wear large bows like the other girls at school. I let her wear them but she doesn’t seem to care about it really.
The Hermione costume is awesome and I’m glad she chose to be Hermione instead of what the pack is going to be.
pomelo / 5866 posts
LO is just growing out of her princess stage (almost 6). She now sees Pokémon as more interesting but for no elevated reason other than she likes the game. I thought she would never grow out of pink and sparkly as none of our family ever encouraged that. It was just part of her preferences from early on. But there she was yesterday, wanting to wear her green shorts (previously a boy color to her) because they were not so hot as the other choices.
So I guess I am learning I can not predict what phase LO will go through next and even princesses
can change.
There was one year in preschool LO didn’t like her costume and wanted to change it at the last second and I had to do some persuasion to keep her focused. You did a great job talking LO through. So good to hear how you connected her to solid values of character! She is adorable.
blogger / olive / 53 posts
This breaks my heart and scares me to death. We avoid “princess” stuff in our house, but I know it will get to her one day. I love the Hermione costume (and her reason) and good job reminding her why she chose it.
blogger / pomegranate / 3300 posts
@JCCovi: I work at a preschool and elementary school and it is a bit eye opening. the 2/3 year old class seems fine but when they get to 4/5 it all stars and it is crazy!
Amber – The short story is she has 3 second grade brothers so she gets to see things a little earlier than she might if she was my oldest. With Harry Potter I read the books to my boys when they were 5, she was 2. She sat with us and read the book so I let her watch the movie with us and she was hooked. With x-men our sons wanted to know about wolverine because they had seen him in all the toy stores and things so we started watching the original x-men cartoons on Hulu and they loved them. She was really excited to pick an x-men costume when we decided to us it as our family costumes.
@Alivoo01: Thank you. It is a constant worry of mine, the teen years have me terrified.
@mediagirl: I know I see it all the time. I’m glad the little girl said she liked her jammies. It is such a shame that the culture of putting each other down starts so young.
@Run2shore: Thank you, and it really is shocking.
@psw27: It makes me sad too. I see it all the time in the pre-k group.
@Mrs. Bee: thank you
@Mrs. Pickle: Thank you, she was an awesome little Hermione. She walked around saying it’s levi-O-sa not levioo-SA. It was a fun Halloween.
@kellyrae: My daughter also likes the princesses but she hates those sparkly itchy dresses so she never wants to dress up as one. I love that she picked a bat. That’s so fun!
@808love: Thank you. Their preferences can change so fast! I bought my daughter a bunch of dresses for her school uniforms because previously that was all she would wear. the first day of school she was like “I like skirts and shirts now, not dresses.” Drove me nuts
@Mrs. Tornado: Thank you, she did love her Hermione costume.