Mrs Blue asked for a post about what it’s like to be an identical twin! So out of love for the Blue family (and the twin baby blues!), here goes.
Being a twin is a very intimate experience. I remember reading at some point in childhood that identical twins were once a single cell. That made intuitive sense to me, as the closeness of my twinship is difficult for me to convey without the biology. I long ago decided that most people couldn’t understand twinship and no longer bother to explain it!
I thought about doing a “pros and cons of being a twin” list, but there are plenty of those on the net. So I thought I’d share a few secrets about being a twin… for all the parents of multiples out there.
1) Birth order matters!
My brother is only four minutes older, but he might as well have been four years older! He was definitely the older brother, and the leader of our two man gang. Growing up, when people would speak to me, I would just turn to my brother and he would answer for me. My parents got so concerned that one day, they told us that we had been switched at birth and I was actually the older one. We just laughed at them.
But when we grew up and I became an adult, I actually had trouble with public speaking. I worked through it, but I knew right away that it was related to my twinship. On the flip side though, I was always very willing to take business/career risks – just like a lot of other younger siblings.
My main point here is that a lot of people think that twins are one unit, and that they’re basically the same age. In my experience, this wasn’t true! Birth order matters, perhaps even more for twins than for other siblings.
2) It can be really liberating to do your own thing
It goes without saying that most people can’t tell you apart, either in person or on the phone. It would be depressing to have friends call the house for me, then get my brother and talk to him… then hang up. I remember when I learned the word “fungible,” I thought “Yes, that’s what it is like to be a twin.”
Growing up, my brother and I did a lot of the same things. We were in the same classes (usually there’d be two teachers that shared classrooms, and we’d each be in one of the classes), we both took piano and violin classes from the same teacher, and we both competed on weekends in the same music competitions.
Then in high school, I started powerlifting and put on 50 pounds of muscle and played football (on my own). I wish I hadn’t waited until then to do something on my own. But I’m so glad that I did!
3) Twins can either be best friends or rivals
This is another one of those things that’s true for both siblings and twins. I remember when I realized this: my brother and I were playing Monopoly with a friend, and we kept trying to beat each other by trading properties with our friend. He of course played us off each other until he crushed us both.
After that, I decided my brother was my ally not my enemy. That was a turning point in my life.
I think in retrospect, it was maybe a bit dangerous to compete against each other in regular piano competitions most weekends. But we turned it into a positive so that if either of us did well, we would both be happy. Win/wins are really important when you’re growing up with a twin or close sibling, I think.
4) It’s common to have a love/hate relationship with twinship
I loved it in so many ways… but also hated it. But it turned out to be such huge part of my life, and I can’t imagine life without a twin. I read that for a lot of twins, the death of their twin is as hard (or in some cases, harder) as the death of their spouse. I can’t imagine either, but wasn’t surprised to learn that there’s a support group called, “Twinless Twins Support Group International.”
5) Encourage specialization
This really helps minimize competition. My brother dated blondes and I dated brunettes. We never fought over girls; problem solved.
6) A few practical tips for parents of multiples
For the love of all that is holy, please do not dress your children in matching outfits. I was not a fan. If possible, don’t put twins in the same room in a bunk bed. Also, don’t make your twins share clothes (especially underwear). It may be easier, but it’s a subtle sign that you’re the same person.
Good luck to Mr. and Mrs. Blue, and all parents of multiples out there!!
Twins/triplets and parents of multiples… what tips would you add?
persimmon / 1165 posts
Great post! At what age do you think it’s healthy for separation/specialization, in terms of separate rooms, clothes, etc.?
GOLD / cantaloupe / 6581 posts
I have two twin sisters, and you are right on the money! The only difference is they were born identical but due to health problems, ended up looking fraternal. Mom still dressed them alike, and they shared a room up until at least middle school. I’m sometimes very jealous of the bond they have; even when they are fighting, they are each other’s best support! It’s definitely an interesting experience being an older sister to twins!
wonderful clementine / 24134 posts
Really, they can’t dress up matching!!!! Its so cute!
pomegranate / 3414 posts
I too am an identical twin and I second what Mr.Bee says. Other thoughts:
– Encourage individuality, my sister and I fought constantly (well more bickered) until went to separate colleges and were out of the others shadow.
-My dad still can’t tell us apart on the phone (although caller ID helps him he still gets it wrong on occasion).
-If you insist on the matching outfit thing, at least put them in different colors, don’t do it constantly, and stop early.
-If they have to share a bedroom, when older, let them each have input into the decor which may lead to some interesting combinations but allows self-expression.
-Treat them as the individuals they are; there was a stage in our lives where everyone (except family) would just refer to us as “twin” rather than figuring out who they were talking to.
-My parents were really good about not keeping everything exactly even, especially at birthdays and Christmas. They didn’t stress over the number of presents but rather the total cost per child and what we asked for. If I wanted a pricey item then that may be all I got whereas my sister might have gotten 6 lower cost items.
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@sunshineandsushi: would the kids have separate rooms if they weren’t twins? If so, I’d give them each their own room.
@Thehistoryofus: it’s just tough if you’re trying to establish your own identity, but you look identical to and are dressed just like your sibling!
GOLD / wonderful apricot / 22276 posts
I like how you stress the individuality, we do not have twins (so far) but I always said, if I did, we would treat them as singletons. Great post, thanks for sharing!
GOLD / papaya / 10166 posts
@mrbee: I’ve always been intrigued with twins and jealous of their bond… so much so, that I have always wanted to have twins and hoped DD was actually twins. Thank you for posting
@purrpletulips: Great advice – thank you!
coconut / 8234 posts
I have identical twin brothers. My mom dressed them in matching outfits for a long time. My brothers also have very similar names–only one letter is different.
Lots of our family/friends/neighbors called them “Twin” and they hated it. My brothers are very very different (one is effeminate and gay, the other is football jock straight) and didn’t like this at all. I would remind people that they have names!
It was so interesting to watch my brothers grow up. @mrbee: did you and your brother your own language? For the first 4-5 years of their lives my brothers had their own language–we grew to know some of the words, but we were all pretty amazed by it.
grapefruit / 4817 posts
I have twin brothers, and while we call them “the boys,” I sometimes forget they are twins. They are identical, but really so so different. They are best friends, but fight terribly some days and have had times over the years where their competitiveness has gotten the best of them. My parents never dressed them alike and they have always been seen in our family as individuals, but they just recently (10th grade) decided that they wanted separate rooms. It’s an amazing relationship to watch.
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@mrsjazz: yah we had our own language. That plus being born overseas meant that I had an accent til I went to speech therapy in 4th-6th grade.
I was gonna say in the post, don’t do the similar name thing! It just adds to the conflation of two people into one!!
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@bree72: Most twins dont like being called, the boys! I was called that too and really disliked it…
blogger / pomelo / 5361 posts
Ahh, Mr. Bee, you always come through for me! Thanks so much for this post! It is truly helpful to have insight from a twin on what to do and not to do. In one of the books I’ve been reading, it said, “Your twins should be treated like two separate children who happened to be born on the same day.” That really resonated with me and seems to match up with your post.
I’m so interested to see how our boys line up with birth order. It’s so funny to watch them in the u/s because they already seem to follow birth order, but who knows if that will still be like that when they come out. Baby A always is doing what he’s supposed to do just like a typical oldest child: he has his head down, sits still when they are trying to monitor him, etc. Baby B is wiggling, putting his bottom on Baby A’s face, and I swear he’s being silly to make sure we notice him! He acts just like my second brother! I know that they don’t have that developed of thinking at this point, but I can’t help but wander if their personalities now already match their (likely) birth order!
@mrsjazz: @purrpletulips: If people refer to my boys as “Twin,” I just might have to cut someone. That’s so rude!
P.S. I swear I won’t always call them “the boys” but we’re just not telling their names yet! Names that don’t “match” for the record!
grapefruit / 4817 posts
@mrbee: Honestly, I think it has more to do with the fact that my older sister and I were called “the girls” most of our life. We’re not twins, but were the first grandkids and nieces in our family by quite a few years. Until we were both out of the house for a number of year, we were “the girls,” so I think it was more a natural progression of that. It’ll be interesting to see once my brothers move up and out if it changes. They really have different aspirations in life, so I can see them both heading different directions. As for my younger sister, she’s just called by her name. What can I say, she’s the wild card.
pear / 1723 posts
Prioritize one on one time with each twin. We intentionally built this into the bedtime routine so even if the day is chaos, each child gets some quality time alone with just mom and just dad before sleep each night.
Be present. Goes for all parents, but with multiples your attention is always divided, especially at the beginning. So I try to make sure it’s not divided further by always watching tv or being on the computer, etc.
hostess / wonderful watermelon / 39513 posts
So interesting! I love #5!
coconut / 8234 posts
@bree72: Same thing for our family. My sister and I were “the girls” and my brothers were “the boys” but I don’t think it had anything to do with them being twins, more to do with gender.
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21616 posts
@mrbee: @Mrs. Blue: interesting on the “boys” comment. I had three brothers growing up and we always just called them “the boys”, but none of them were twins, they were 4 and 6 years apart. I suppose it’s different if it’s twins?
I love this post – very cool! I kind of secretly wish for twins – but I know it would be so difficult in the early years as well! I do remember as a kid being so jealous of my twin friends! haha.
@mrbee: does your brother has a matching name?
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@bree72: @mrsjazz: Sometimes the same words can have a different impact on different people, I think?
When you’re identical to someone else in appearance, voice and more, carving out your own identity can sometimes take on an outsized importance! At least, that was my experience. I treasured everyone who could recognize my voice and appearance, and called me by my name.
admin / wonderful grape / 20724 posts
@Mrs. Pen: Our names don’t alliterate or rhyme, thankfully!
coconut / 8234 posts
@mrbee: I agree and I’ll have to ask them how they felt about “the boys.” –I know they hated “Twin.” But my sister and I were “the girls” before my brothers came along.
cantaloupe / 6146 posts
@mrbee: My brother and I were called “they boys” too…. Don’t think that’s a twin exclusive.
Very interesting post!
blogger / watermelon / 14218 posts
Love this post! I’ve always been so intrigued by twins. If I had identical twins I would probably do the same/similar outfit, different colors thing. But I would definitely have one wardrobe for one twin and a different wardrobe for the other twin (therefore not forcing them to share clothes). Like one boy in blue, one in green… one girl in pink, one in purple… etc. Good point about not sharing underwear, @Mr. Bee… !!! Never thought about that but I’d definitely hate to share underwear with someone!!
Wagon Sr. and his brother are 18 months apart and shared a room with bunk beds until college! Haha. They were always mistaken for twins.
pomegranate / 3716 posts
@mrbee: What an interesting post! And I had to look up “fungible”
guest
LOL @ #5!
hostess / wonderful honeydew / 32460 posts
Great post!!! Your underwear sharing statement made me lol
GOLD / wonderful coffee bean / 18478 posts
Oh my, how awful to think of yourself as being “fungible”. Great tips!
persimmon / 1180 posts
I haven’t read all the replies, but, as a twin, don’t compare them to each other. They are two different people! One may be better at something than the other and that’s ok! Let them be unique individuals.
coffee bean / 41 posts
This is really interesting, and I’ve never heard about twinship from a man, so I really enjoyed reading your perspective–thanks for sharing!
guest
So…. I didn’t pay attention to who wrote this, and thought it was Mrs. Bee, until I got to the part about powerlifting and putting on 50 lbs. duh. Damn sleep deprivation!
kiwi / 691 posts
My brothers are twins and loved sharing a room! I always thought it was crazy, but they shared a room through high school. They went to separate colleges at first, but then one transferred in his junior year so they finished the last two years together. I don’t think I ever saw or heard them fight when we were growing up. I was always so jealous of how close they were!
GOLD / cantaloupe / 6703 posts
My husband and I both have twin sisters, and it’s so interesting looking at the differences in our relationships with them. My sister and I grew up in a small community where we were in the same classroom all but one year before high school. We played on the same sports teams, everything. We are just now, at 26, starting to get along. There was so much comparison and rivalry that it was hard to be a twin. I used to say that there was no way I’d want to have twins because of my experience.
My husband and his sister grew up with more opportunities to be individuals, and they get along. She was his “protector” because he had a bad speech impediment when younger. They were always in different classrooms and encouraged to do their own thing. In high school, she developed some issues and he became her protector.
Also, birth order in twins is huge! I’m a classic first born, DH is definitely a youngest!
blogger / wonderful cherry / 21628 posts
Interesting post!
nectarine / 2152 posts
I’m having twins!!! But they are a boy and a girl, which will hopefully cut out some of the ‘sameness’ issues…so excited tho!
blogger / eggplant / 11551 posts
Great post!
My best friend is a triplet and they all hated taking “triplet pictures” together growing up, and never did until college. People often called them “the triplets” and they really didn’t like that. The birth order thing definitely rang true for them too. There was a distinct oldest, middle, and baby!
coffee bean / 32 posts
Thank you for this! I’m always excited to read “twins” posts, because I have 18 month old identical twin boys. We do our best to encourage them as individuals and as of now they don’t even pay much attention to each other! Although, I get the feeling they always know when the other is around and when they’re not. My oldest is much more talkative as well, while his brother is much more “hands-on”/always getting into something
I’m glad they have such different personalities.
And even though they share clothes now (2 is $$$), I will remember to buy them they’re own underwear when the time comes